Marketplace   Menu Guide   Complete Pages      
butler eagle
Site last updated: Wednesday, December 17, 2014 Bookmark our site!
Local PennsylvaniaNationalInternationalNews Extras  
Published: May 14, 2013 print this article Print save this article Save email this article Email ENLARGE TEXT increase font decrease font

Shaming was wrong

There is no legal authority in the state of Pennsylvania for Allegheny County Judge Lester Nauhaus’ act of shaming former state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin by summoning her to his chambers to be forcibly posed handcuffed, then photographed by the county photographer.
After that, Orie Melvin was required to purchase and sign 500 copies with the words “I’m sorry.” A copy is to be sent to every judge in the state.
This was an unforgivable, sadistic act of which Orie Melvin and the people of Pennsylvania deserve better. I don’t believe the judge would have treated a male defendant similarly.
Attorneys and judges should treat all persons in court with dignity.




Robert F. Hawk, Esq.
Butler Township
Back
 
Comments
Order Photos!
 
MORE LETTERS TO THE EDITOR HEADLINES
arrow ‘Don’t excuse it’
arrow None of your business
arrow DEER KILL - Sheppeck
arrow Her father’s politics
 
MOST READ ARTICLES
arrow Butler Twp puts off vote on shopping complex
arrow Parents make plea to keep schools
arrow Police reports
arrow Congressman Kelly to be part owner of BlueSox