Site last updated: Monday, September 14, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

FIELDING CRITICISM AT MARS

Mars High School students, decked out in red, white and blue, cheer at the start of Friday's football game against visiting Penn Hills. Social media posts on both Facebook and Twitter, as well as calls to talk radio stations Monday, questioned the theme.
USA theme at game sparks discord

ADAMS TWP — Despite some criticism of Mars fans during Friday’s football game with Penn Hills, officials from the districts and the athletic league said Monday that no formal complaints have been lodged.

Social media posts on both Facebook and Twitter, as well as calls to local talk radio stations Monday, called into question the America theme night used by the Mars student section. Students were dressed in red, white and blue, with many waving American flags and flags adorned with President Donald Trump’s name.

Those commenting said they found it odd that the theme was chosen for the contest.

“What does it mean when you have Trump signs at a football game and chant ‘U.S.A. U.S.A.’ to encourage your team while playing against a predominantly African American team? Do you realize that Penn Hills is in the United States and the African American players are from the U.S.A.?” wrote one Twitter user.

“I watched that game on TV last night and I said it was odd that they picked a U.S.A. theme to play Penn Hills,” wrote another.

Others questioned the use of a sign depicting Penn Hills quarterback Hollis Mathis and chants of “overrated.”

On Monday, Nancy Hines, Penn Hills superintendent, said she had received “a few questions” about the theme night.

“Several of our fans wished they had known in advance, as they would have liked to dress in red, white and blue also to show solidarity and our unity as Americans,” she wrote in an email.

Tim O’Malley, Western Pennsylvania Interscholastic Athletic League executive director, said the league has received no complaints from the game. Likewise, Wes Shipley, superintendent of the Mars School District, said he had heard no complaints.

In a letter to parents Monday, Shipley wrote that district administrators completed a “thorough investigation” into allegations raised on a radio program, which alleged racial and inflammatory statements were made. The letter said state officials could not find any evidence that the incident took place.

Shipley said any such behavior is not tolerated and should be reported to the district’s 24-hour hot line. He added that school policy dictates any student found to be violating district policy faces disciplinary action.

“As parents/guardians, we also encourage you to please talk with your students about appropriate behavior in school and at district events,” the letter states. “Only with your assistance can we guarantee a positive school environment for all students.”

Hines said she heard from others who noted the “unusual amount of attention” on Mathis, including the poster bearing his image.

“Several Penn Hills fans, students included, thought that was in poor taste,” she said. “I would agree after seeing the poster during the live television broadcast I watched.”

The game was played at the end of a week in which Penn Hills canceled all sporting events with the Connellsville Area School District over an incident that allegedly took place Sept. 6. In that incident, Penn Hills students were allegedly called racial slurs during a varsity soccer match.

WPIAL officials were reportedly investigating that matter Monday.

In Friday’s game, Penn Hills handed Mars its first loss of the season, 36-15.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS