Director's charges detailed
GROVE CITY — The bevy of charges on Cecelia Yauger’s credit card statements from October 2007 through February 2013 highlight the need for a forensic audit to decipher them.
Timothy McNickle, Midwestern Intermediate Unit IV solicitor, ordered the audit in April after a Pittsburgh attorney requested the former executive director’s credit card statements in a Right-to-Know request.
The preliminary results of the audit were shared with the MIU IV’s board May 22.
“The board has seen the preliminary results and is awaiting a final report which will be shared with the public,” said J. Dayle Ferguson, an MIU IV board member who also is the Mars School Board president.
“I wish I could be more helpful, but there’s a process here and we need to respect the process,” she said.
The Butler Eagle obtained copies of the bills through a Right-to-Know request to the agency.
The client of attorney Antoinette Oliver, who initially sought the credit card information, has never come forward, and Oliver has not returned calls for comment.
The forensic audit will determine which of tens-of-thousand of dollars in charges paid for by taxpayers are legitimate and which ones Yauger will have to repay to the agency under her separation agreement.
In addition to restitution, Yauger agreed to forfeit her sick days and vacation days she had accumulated and for which she would have been paid $100 per day.
Yauger resigned as executive director on April 12. She had earned $124,840 annually.
A copy of the separation agreement also was obtained by the Eagle through a Right-to-Know request.
On the bills, Yauger’s secretary, Laura Urbach, routinely asked her boss in a handwritten note if all of the charges should be paid by the MIU IV business office. Yauger similarly handwrote her answer, “yes” or “OK” and signed with her initials, “Cy.”
Initially, MIU IV’s business office divided Yauger’s expenses into three categories: cyber expenses from Verizon, travel expenses and those for supplies. Some charges are designated for staff retreats or travel.
A majority of the charges on the bills are for Verizon services, but it’s unclear whether those add up to the majority of the money spent.
There are the odd charges, like the $116 Yauger spent at a Bloomingdale’s in Mason, Ohio, in the Men’s Neckwear department on May 15, 2011, the $208 spent at Finding King, a gift store in Mesa, Ariz., on Dec. 12, 2011, and the multiple charges to the Oriental Trading Company in Omaha, Neb.
But what jumps out are the many charges at retail stores from Erie to Pittsburgh and from Hershey to Sharon, simply referred to as “expenses.”
Multiple charges at Walmart, Target and Costco share space with charges at Penn State shops, drug stores and specialty stores such as chocolate shops, florists, the Wendell August Forge, Angie’s Attic and Kirkland’s.
There also are numerous charges at craft stores including Pat Catan’s, Jo-Ann Fabric and Craft Stores and Michael’s. Then there are the charges at TJ Maxx in multiple locations, record stores, card shops, bookstores and the Party City in Cranberry Township.
Numerous meals at Grove City-area restaurants were charged to the card, as were Redbox DVD rentals.
Even American Express became suspicious, asking if charges made at Big Lots and Ruby Tuesday on Friday, Aug. 26, 2011, were legitimate.
McNickle could not be reached regarding the release date of the auditor’s final report, which is being prepared by Ohio-based Hill Barth & King, LLP.
Yauger is being investigated for theft by the Grove City Police Department, said Chief Dean E. Osborne.
“The grading of a theft is determined by the amount of money involved,” according to state statute, Osborne said.
Any theft of more than $2,000 is a felony, he said. He will share the results with the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the U.S. Department of Education’s office of the inspector general.
The MIU IV is part of the state Department of Education and is funded with federal, state and local tax dollars.
The statements show that Robert Barber, the MIU IV’s director of business services, held a second credit card for the account. His expenditures, which are less than Yauger’s, have not been called into question.
The MIU IV is one of 29 regional education agencies under the state Department of Education. In Butler County, it serves Butler, Karns City, Mars, Moniteau, Seneca Valley, Slippery Rock and South Butler school districts and the Butler Area Vocational-Technical schools. It also serves 20 other districts in Mercer and Lawrence counties.
MIU IV’s 60 budgets total more than $100 million.
It is seeking a new executive director.
