Mistrial declared in case of Chester County man charged in 2021 homicide
A defense attorney raised his voice in frustration while objecting to the testimony of a witness whose statement prompted a mistrial in a homicide case that had been building for six years.
Defense attorney Matthew Ness requested a mistrial in the first day of proceedings Monday, Nov. 16, for Paris Carter, 28, of Downingtown, who is charged with homicide in the May 17, 2021, shooting death of David A. Hines, 38, of New Castle.
The mistrial was requested after witness Tashane Henry, who was in the vehicle when the murder occurred, testified about an incident that occurred in another state days after the murder. The information was restricted from being presented at the trial due to the possibility it could taint the jury.
Ness argued the jury could use the statement to make a conclusion that could create bias against the defendant.
“The judge can give limiting perspective, but everyone in the room heard it,” Ness said, expressing frustration about the mistrial after six years on the case.
Assistant District Attorney Robert Zanella introduced more than 20 photos and videos as evidence and testimony was heard from Hines and three past and present members of the state police who investigated the case before the mistrial was declared.
Zanella did not object to the mistrial. District Attorney Richard Goldinger said he was “obviously disappointed” with the result and is eager for another trial.
Hines’ mother said she came from Oklahoma to the trial. She also expressed frustration a mistrial was called.
During opening statements, Zanella said the jury of five men and seven women would hear testimony from Henry, who was driving the vehicle at the time of the shooting, and others to prove Carter shot Hines twice in the head.
Ness argued the evidence presented by Zanella would not be able to rule out if it were actually Henry who pulled the trigger.
Before the mistrial was declared, Henry became emotional while testifying about his relationship with Carter and the events leading up to the shooting. Henry said he’d known Carter about 10 years before the incident.
The day of the shooting, Henry, Carter, his brother Dante Carter and Hines had gone to a New Castle bar then to Hines’ girlfriend’s house to hang out.
The group eventually drove to Pittsburgh and were there a short time before driving back, according to testimony. Henry said the group stopped on the way back and he was asked to drive.
Henry’s testimony about what he saw just before and during the shooting led to the mistrial.
According to previous court records, Paris and Dante Carter and Henry abandoned the vehicle after Hines was killed and fled to Bear Run Campground where they were picked up by Henry’s girlfriend. Paris Carter stayed the night at Henry’s home and was driven to Philadelphia the next day, according to testimony.
A passerby found Hines’ body sitting in the front passenger seat of a vehicle abandoned along Portersville Road in Muddy Creek Township.
Jury selection for a new trial has been scheduled for Dec. 2 and 3 with the trial to begin Dec. 7, according to Zanella.
