Butler’s Councilwoman Quebedeaux outlines plan to rewrite city’s rental ordinance
Butler City Councilwoman Lisa Quebedeaux has outlined and presented a plan to revise the city’s rental property condition report. However, her plan to improve housing in the city does not end there.
In addition to changing the report, she said it requires a full rewrite of the rental occupancy chapter of the city code.
The biggest change would be introducing a tenant bill of rights that would lay out the specific rights and responsibilities of a tenant when they are renting in the city.
“So many people I’ve talked to have no idea what their rights and responsibilities are. Or worse yet, their expectations or assumptions have been erroneously conditioned by people doing it for their profit,” she said.
She said profit motivation routinely manifests in the City of Butler as landlords pointing to structural damage, plumbing or other issues and claiming it is the tenant’s responsibility to remediate.
“This establishes the rules of the game. It’s going to make a lot less friction because we have an even playing field,” she said.
She said the rights as currently drafted include access to a habitable space with Americans with Disabilities Act compliance and clearly defined rules for when and how usage of the security deposit is valid.
“It’s just sort of specifying that if you’re going to use that security deposit for damages, before you take that money, you must give the tenant an opportunity to make those repairs,” she explained.
More rights in her proposal include the right to transfer utility costs, rights related to privacy, the right to a fair hearing and freedom from intimidation or coercion.
“There were two tenants I was working with, and one of them was threatened. Their landlord said ‘I’m going to evict you because you’re working with city hall to deal with some code violations.’ So what did she do? She said ‘let me walk that back.’ And so those property condition issues and code violations are going to continue because we can only act if there’s some sort of report,” she said.
She said the freedom from intimidation goes hand-in-hand with the right to just-cause eviction, where a landlord can only evict if the lease is broken.
“A lease is a legal agreement between two parties, not a unilateral power structure where only the landlord determines if you’re in or you’re out. If you say you’re here for 12 months by these conditions, those are the conditions,” she said.
While not directly part of the tenant bill of rights, a point of pride for Quebedeaux in her proposal is instilling some protections for domestic violence survivors. She said her work on this did not just come from other city codes but also from discussions with VOICE, a victim intervention organization.
She explained some of the changes with a scenario many real survivors have endured.
“If you boot out your abuser and report them, they’re back the next day because they have keys to your apartment,” she said.
With the new rental ordinance, tenants would have the legal right to have their locks changed, as long as the landlord is involved in the discussion and the tenant pays for the work.
Another major protection is the ability to end a lease over domestic violence.
“Another very common thing is, ‘I felt like I couldn’t leave my abuser because of financial obligations. I still have another 11 months of this lease and I’d be homeless.’ If there is a court order that says there was an abusive situation in the household, (the ordinance) provides the survivor a right to give 30 days’ notice,” Quebedeaux explained.
She said the tenant would be obligated to pay rent for the remaining 30 days, but would then be able to vacate the property with no penalty.
“That, to me, is a highly prudent modern evolution for the City of Butler,” she said.
She said if these protections are passed, she hopes VOICE reminds survivors of these new options.
Another specified right Quebedeaux wants to include in the tenant bill of rights is the right to “receive, view and annotate” the property condition report to keep it as a working document that protects landlords and tenants.
She said tenants could clearly disagree if there were a conflict and landlords could use the document as part of proof for an eviction or other remediative efforts.
Furthermore, the new rental ordinance would include a clearly defined list of duties for tenants and landlords.
“It specifies beyond the condition report, what are (landlords’) expectations? Roof, foundation, structural things like walls, ceilings and interior walls and sanitary systems,” she explained.
Tenant duties mostly revolve around avoiding damage to the property and paying for repairs whenever applicable.
“It specifies don’t damage the property, and if you do, there’s legal recourse for the landlord to take from your deposit or to evict you,” she said.
Everything Quebedeaux is proposing for enforcement is “in line with what third class cities are allowed to do,” she said.
“We presently have similar fines for being noncompliant, and it’s just sort of a continuation of that,” she said.
While Quebedeaux presented her proposed changes to the condition report at a city forum meeting Nov. 5, her rewrite of the rental ordinance has yet to be presented to council.
Nevertheless, she said she expects several months of discussions and legal review before it is a finalized ordinance ready for vote.
“I want us to go through this piece by piece, talk about it and identify the places that we think are really dynamite and need to stay here. Some of the parts might need a little more discussion,” she said.
Quebedeaux said she believes council will find most of these changes to be common sense if members read up on similar cities’ codes. However, her bigger hurdle is making sure the language is legally sound.
“I’m not a lawyer. I work in housing policy, but I’m not going to pretend to be a legal expert. (Solicitor Tom Breth) will probably have edits and changes. He might have his own commentary that maybe this will work, maybe this won’t work, so we’ll see,” she said.
She said in the best of scenarios, she hopes it could become city law as soon as spring 2027, but recognizes that it is a large revision that may require longer.
She said she is also working to go to Erie with Mayor Bob Dandoy to discuss what challenges city council faced when enacting their new rental ordinance.
Quebedeaux initially planned to present the rental ordinance at the Nov. 5 meeting with adjustments to the property condition report, but refrained to give council time to digest the proposed report. That discussion is likely to come at a future city council meeting.
The proposed changes to the property condition report will be discussed at a special meeting from 1 to 2 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 19. Depending on the outcome of that meeting a vote could occur at the city’s next meeting, set for 7 p.m. Monday, Nov. 23.
