Saving the Penn Theater
For decades, the Penn Theater stood in the heart of downtown Butler as a beacon of culture and connectivity that shined across our region.
It was more than just a destination for seeing a movie. It was the centerpiece of a local adventure, which often included participating in other activities like shopping along Main Street or visiting Butler’s downtown eateries.
I have heard many stories from people who are now our seniors regarding how, when they were young, a family trip to the Penn Theater and a stop at the old Hot Dog Shop were the cornerstone of a great Saturday. Throw in a visit to Aland’s Toy Store, and it became a big deal. The fact is that if you were born and raised in Butler County or have lived here for several decades or more, the odds are good that you have a fond memory of visiting Penn Theater.
Butler native Bryan Frenchak was certainly familiar with the theater when he graduated high school in 1975 and left the area to pursue what turned out to be a highly-successful career. Years later, when he returned to Butler with his lovely wife, Marina, the state and status of the theater had certainly changed. Sitting idle and on the brink of demolition, the landmark needed a savior.
Fast forward to November 2023. The soft opening of the Penn Theater earlier this month was a testament to the power of homecoming. As an Eagles tribute band took the stage, belting out familiar tunes that have stood the test of time, it was impossible not to feel the resonance of the lyrics. “You can check out anytime you'd like, but you can never leave” took on a new meaning — a declaration of permanence and a promise to nurture the roots from which one springs.
The Frenchaks’ decision to return to Butler and to invest in the very soul of our community is a greater contribution that can simply be reflected by repairing a structure. Bryan and Marina have not only rescued a building — they have infused life back into the heart of Butler. Their dedication can serve as an example for others who have something to give back to their hometowns. The Penn Theater stands not just as a structure of brick and mortar, but as a symbol of resilience and community spirit.
The Frenchaks deserve a debt of gratitude for their role in preserving the Penn Theater. The impact of their return goes beyond the physical walls of the building. The Penn Theater can be a catalyst for continued revitalization of Butler’s Downtown. Just as it was a beacon of culture and connectivity decades ago, the Penn Theater is poised to return to that focus and purpose, inspiring other business opportunities in downtown Butler along the way.
As for my own favorite memory at the Penn Theater, it is seeing the original cinematic release of the movie “Grease,” starring John Travolta and Olivia Newton-John, in 1978. However, who knows. Thanks to the Frenchaks, we will all have future opportunities to make lasting memories.
Marci Mustello is a Pennsylvania state representative for District 11.
