Site last updated: Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Fight results in probation

Andrew Freshwater
Community service will be autism-related

A 25-year-old man, who was sentenced Monday to serve three years' probation for his role in a deadly fist fight, agreed to seek out community service projects related to autism.

The victim, 22-year-old Christopher A. Kutchell of Butler, had an autism diagnosis.

Kutchell died following a May 3, 2012, altercation outside the then-home of defendant Andrew Freshwater in the 400 block of Virginia Avenue in Butler's Island neighborhood.

According to court records, Freshwater twice punched Kutchell in the jaw, causing him to fall backward. Kutchell's head hit the concrete sidewalk. He died at Butler Memorial Hospital of a fractured skull.

Freshwater pleaded no contest to involuntary manslaughter.

Initially, Freshwater also was charged with reckless endangerment and the felony charge of aggravated assault. Those charges, however, were dropped in exchange for his plea.

Under state law, involuntary manslaughter is the least severe of the homicide offenses, a misdemeanor. A person commits involuntary manslaughter if another person dies as a result of a “reckless or grossly negligent” act. It is not murder.

A no contest plea implies the defendant is not acknowledging guilt but rather is choosing not to fight the allegation at a trial. Still, the plea is given the same weight as a guilty plea for the purpose of sentencing.

During his hearing, Freshwater said he was sorry about Kutchell's death which he referred to as both a “terrible tragedy” and an “accident.”

Members of the victim's family attended the hearing and cried in the courtroom. They did not speak and declined to comment afterward.

Butler County Judge Timothy McCune said he read letters from Kutchell's mother and aunt before the hearing. Based on those letters, the judge agreed to ask Freshwater to seek out community service programs related to autism.

Defense attorney R. Anthony DeLuca of Pittsburgh told the judge that Freshwater has moved to a shore town in North Carolina that doesn't have a lot of programs related to autism.

DeLuca said Freshwater moved to work in the construction industry with his father and support his two children. Freshwater was accompanied in the courtroom by a handful of family members, including a boy.

In addition to the probation and 200 hours of community service, Freshwater was ordered to pay more than $10,000 in restitution to the victim's family and to a state fund that compensates crime victims.

DeLuca told the judge that he had recommended his client have a trial, but Freshwater wanted to take the plea because he wanted to end the court hearings for his family as well as the victim's family.

Assistant District Attorney Mark Lope, who prosecuted the case, said the victim's diagnosis of autism was not a factor in the plea offer to Freshwater.

Instead, Lope, who also stressed the tragedy of the situation, said the totality of the circumstances made the offer the right resolution, including the fact that the fatal fight occurred on Freshwater's property.

The defense also had earlier argued in court that Freshwater had been defending himself against Kutchell, who at the time of the fatal argument had been drinking and apparently was belligerent and agitated over something not related to Freshwater. According to previous testimony, Freshwater alleges Kutchell “called him out” and threw the first punch unprovoked.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS