Site last updated: Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Eckstein defends conduct

Jim Eckstein

Butler County Commissioner Jim Eckstein continues to defend his conduct, saying his job isn’t to be politically correct.

“Politics is a rough business,” he said at the commissioners’ meeting Wednesday.

Eckstein was responding to the findings of a Pittsburgh firm hired to investigate an internal sexual discrimination complaint filed against him by an employee.

Although the firm Thomas, Thomas & Hafer concluded there was insufficient evidence to establish sexual discrimination, it did state Eckstein’s behavior is leaving the county open to potential litigation.

Eckstein disagreed, saying he has the right to ask questions.

Several sources previously identified chief clerk Amy Wilson as the employee who filed the complaint.

Neither Wilson nor Eckstein would verify she is the employee.

County solicitor Mike English said in an interview he could not confirm who filed the complaint because it is a personnel issue.

According to Eckstein, the complaint stemmed from a discussion he had with that employee following the December county prison board meeting.

He criticized the firm for not interviewing him before talking to nine witnesses.

“I don’t call that fair,” Eckstein said.

English, who unsuccessfully tried to convince Eckstein to drop the topic, said he couldn’t comment on the specifics.

But English did say the firm followed proper procedure for conducting such an investigation.

Eckstein reiterated the county wasted roughly $5,000 on the investigation when the complaint could have been addressed other ways.

English said during the interview the county is obligated to investigate discrimination complaints,

He conceded the county was limited in what action could be taken against an elected official.

However, he said advising an official to cease engaging in certain behaviors would benefit the county if it faced litigation down the road due to the actions of that official.

“Things can be done to protect the county from any liability,” English said.

During the meeting, Eckstein read a summary of the 12-page report filed by the firm May 9.

Commissioner Bill McCarrier pointed out Eckstein emphasized there was insufficient evidence of sexual discrimination while omitting the investigation’s conclusion that Eckstein mistreats people.

McCarrier accused Eckstein of painting a “rosy” picture of the situation.

Even though he was found to have not committed sex discrimination, Eckstein stressed the difference between sex discrimination and sexual harassment.

According to the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, sex discrimination is when someone is treated unfavorably due to the person’s gender.

Examples of sexual harassment are when an employee receives unwelcome sexual advances or requests for sexual favors.

This was the second allegation of sex discrimination filed against Eckstein. Joyce Ainsworth, director of county Children and Youth Services, in 2012 filed a complaint with the EEOC.

The commissioners last December settled that case by agreeing to attend training covering such topics as bullying in the workplace and issuing a statement of support.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS