Between 1921-43, the Butler High and Mars football teams battled 19 times, with Butler holding a 15-2-2 lead in the series.

Year Winner Score1921 Tie 7-71922 Butler 12-01924 Butler 25-01925 Mars 12-01926 Mars 6-01927 Butler 12-71928 Butler 7-01929 Butler 41-01930 Butler 31-61931 Butler 25-01932 Butler 28-01933 Butler 20-01937 Butler 33-01938 Butler 20-01939 Butler 31-01940 Butler 14-01941 Butler 33-01942 Butler 41-01943 Tie 0-0