Site last updated: Thursday, September 11, 2025

Log In

Reset Password
MENU
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Best Insurance

Full or limited tort? Identity theft? First party benefits? Health savings accounts?

Is insurance a maze of confusing words and phrases? Have you tried the 800 telephone number companies with cute slogans and mascots where you may not pay much but also don't get much?

It's time you try Butler County's "Main Street" insurance agency: Best Insurance. Since 1917 Best Insurance has been providing good coverage from quality companies with the advantage of someone to talk with who can walk you through that confusing maze.

Whether it's health insurance, business insurance or auto and homeowners insurance, we have a company to provide the coverage you need at a price you'll like.

A sampling of our fine business partners are Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield, Donegal, Ohio Casualty, UPMC, Westfield, Encompass, Health America, Allied and AFLAC. We encourage purchasing responsible liability limits as well as combining car and home to maximize available discounts.

Best Insurance Agency offers a choice of insurance plans and programs, and periodically reviews your coverage to keep up with your changing insurance needs. Customer satisfaction is key to an independent agent's livelihood. Serving you is your independent agent's most important concern.

Whether you speak or meet with our sales staff, Tom Fleming, Cathy Berger-Reese, Jeff Sinz; support staff, Jamie McDonald, Carol Prokay, Michelle Werner Katie Peindl, or one of the owners: Don Best, Carol B. and Rick McClean, Ray Rosenbauer or Mike Reese, you'll appreciate our friendly, hometown atmosphere.

We invite you to give a call at 724-283-5670, check us out online at Bestinsurancebutler.com or stop by our offices at 340 S. Main St., across from the Post Office.

More in Special Sections

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS