Site last updated: Thursday, July 30, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Judge in scandal gets $11K/month

Annual pension totals $134,000

HARRISBURG — The Pennsylvania Supreme Court justice who abruptly retired in late October after being linked to a pornographic e-mail scandal is collecting an $11,000-a-month public pension.

The State Employees’ Retirement System told The Associated Press on Monday that Seamus McCaffery cashed out $455,000 of his own contributions plus compounded interest, leaving him with a $134,000 annual pension.

McCaffery’s years of service included time as a judge in Philadelphia and on state Superior Court and were augmented with 2.6 years of military service. He did not designate anyone to collect a portion of the pension upon his death, which would have decreased his monthly payments.

The elected Democratic justice retired after seven years on the state’s highest court. His colleagues had just suspended him amid ethics investigations that dealt in part with his role sending or receiving e-mails with explicit content or pornographic images.

McCaffery did not return a call Monday to his former chambers, where a phone machine is taking his messages.

He had apologized for his role in the e-mails, in which dozens of current and former employees of the state attorney general’s office have been implicated. Attorney General Kathleen Kane said a month ago that four of her employees had been fired, 11 suspended without pay and others reprimanded or counseled as a result.

McCaffery’s sudden departure from the seven-justice court came shortly after Chief Justice Ron Castille disclosed publicly that McCaffery had sent or received 234 of the e-mails between late 2008 to May 2012.

A fellow justice, Michael Eakin, had also gone public with an accusation that McCaffery tried to coerce him into taking his side against Castille.

McCaffery said Castille had a vendetta against him.

“This latest cooked-up controversy over my personal e-mails is part of a vindictive pattern of attacks by the soon-to-be-retired chief justice,” he said at the time. Castille has reached the mandatory retirement age of 70 and is retiring at the end of this month.

More in Business

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS