Site last updated: Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Commonwealth Court hears arguments on Tri-County Landfill pollution suit

An attorney representing a group of Slippery Rock area residents argued against the dismissal of a lawsuit compelling the DEP to address pollution in a waterway adjacent to a Mercer County landfill that has been plagued by a 38-year-old permitting process.

The lawsuit, filed on behalf of Liberty Township, the Citizens’ Environmental Association of the Slippery Rock Area and seven residents who live near the Tri-County Landfill, requests the state Commonwealth Court to compel the DEP and Tri-County Landfill to address the alleged pollution.

The landfill is owned by Tri-County Industries, a subsidiary of Adams Township’s Vogel Holding.

“It’s time for the department to be held accountable,” said attorney Lisa Johnson, who represents the plaintiffs.

Johnson argued the landfill has polluted the waterway for decades. She argued that in 2022, the DEP’s own experts found the waterway was being polluted by the landfill. She also said the DEP and landfill have not developed total maximum daily load (TMDL) requirements to remedy the pollution.

A TMDL calculates a ceiling for how much a waterway can be polluted and still be considered safe. Attorney David Hall, representing the DEP, explained Pennsylvania has about 2,000 miles of polluted waterways it develops TMDLs for and ranks them by the cause and severity of impairment and the purpose of the waterway, such as for aquatic life, fish consumption, recreation or potable water. It then addresses the polluted waterways by rank.

Johnson argued the nearby waterway is impaired enough to require a TMDL and the DEP has known of its impairment but has not developed one.

The landfill sits on 99 acres in Liberty and Springfield townships. Johnson said it contains more than 1 billion pounds of waste.

In 2025, Commonwealth Court revoked a state-issued permit for the facility to reopen the landfill due to a 1997 regulation the Environmental Quality Board adopted prohibiting landfills within 10,000 feet of an airport runway used by turbine-powered aircraft. A portion of the landfill sits within 10,000 feet of the Grove City Airport in Springfield Township.

The permit had essentially reopened the landfill and allowed waste deposits 24 hours per day, six days per week.

Hall’s preliminary objections focused on how the lawsuit was filed. He said the petitioners failed to notify the DEP of an issue and delayed filing a lawsuit so the issue may be addressed. Hall accused the petitioners of “leapfrogging” the requirements that allow the DEP the time and ability to respond to complaints.

He argued that, according to the federal Clean Water Act, the Clean Streams Law and the Hazardous Sites Cleanup Act, lawsuits alleging inaction by the DEP must be filed as citizen lawsuits, which enable private citizens affected by pollution to sue corporations or governments.

Johnson countered the petitioners had been writing letters to the DEP about the pollution for decades.

Hall responded that the petitioners’ lawsuits should be filed individually in other courts.

“Only this court can give the relief the petitioners are seeking,” Johnson said.

Hall argued the DEP responds to complaints often, but a letter expressing intent to sue is handled differently. Further, he said the DEP is only required to “investigate and ascertain as far as practical.”

Commonwealth Court did not issue a ruling after hearing the arguments Tuesday, Nov. 17.

In 2024, the Pennsylvania Environmental Hearing Board called the proceedings “what must undoubtedly be the most protracted, convoluted permit application process in the history of the commonwealth.”

Related Article: Court denies permit to reopen landfill near Grove City

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS