Site last updated: Saturday, October 3, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

OTHER VOICES

The National Football League should suspend Michael Vick — and not for a short time.

A federal grand jury indicted the Atlanta Falcons star quarterback last week on multiple charges involving a dogfighting operation.

Dogfights are cruel and obnoxious enough, but the indictment also charged that Vick participated in killing dogs that failed to perform in the fighting pit. A variety of grisly means of execution were alleged — from drowning to electrocution.

This, the indictment alleges, occurred at a property Vick bought expressly for the purpose of staging dogfights. Despicable.

The charges carry with them potential penalties of six years in prison plus $350,000 in fines.

Ah, but the presumption of innocence, you say. Discipline must await a jury's verdict. Also, think of the perils of rushing to judgment, a la the Duke lacrosse fiasco.

First, the evidence against Vick is far stronger. Second, the NFL is not the government; the government's power to incarcerate rightly requires the highest standard of proof. The NFL, by contrast, is a high-profile employer with a conduct policy whose reputation clause Vick has violated.

It's also a league trying to tighten up discipline after a spate of lawless incidents by players who seem to think athletic skill and big contracts exempt them from the basic ethical rules with which mere mortals must comply.

The case of Vick — a superstar, not a bit player or a has-been — is a good place to send an overdue deterrent message to these well-paid and much-celebrated young men. The immense rewards of their game come with high responsibility, not with immunity.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS