Site last updated: Wednesday, November 12, 2025

Log In

Reset Password
MENU
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Hunter Scherer, Owen Heginbotham are Karns City football’s picture-perfect pair in the backfield

Karns City running back Owen Heginbotham, 22, runs the ball during the game against Karns City, Friday, Sept. 12, 2025, at Moniteau High School. Matthew Brown/Butler Eagle Matthew Brown/Butler Eagle

KARNS CITY — Hunter Scherer and Owen Heginbotham were once youth football foes.

Picture that.

The two senior Karns City tailbacks spent their first six football seasons hitting each other much more than they do now, where opposing linebackers are now their primary targets.

“We were always the best two running backs going against each other,” said Scherer, who suited up for the Karns City Blue Devils as they’d face off with Heginbotham and the East Brady Bulldogs. “It was fun. He’d tackle me and I’d tackle him. We were both linebackers, too. We played the same positions on both sides of the ball.”

Related Article: High school football Week 5 picks: Punxsutawney vs. Karns City, Butler and Mars look to rebound

Ahead of their matchup with Punxsutawney on Friday night, Heginbotham and Scherer have combined for 613 yards and nine touchdowns on the ground for the Gremlins (3-1). The two have even joined forces in yearbook class, a course no other teammates are in.

“It was always like, ‘Hunter Scherer. That guy. He’s gonna be the guy. You’re on him the entire game,’” Heginbotham said, looking back on their youth football days. “I’m pretty sure I just went back and forth the entire time. So I literally had him man-to-man for at least two years of my peewee days.”

Scherer remembers a young Heginbotham’s physicality and sportsmanship.

“He never opened his mouth or anything,” Heginbotham said. “He was always a very respectful player. He was a pretty hard runner for how small (he was). ... He still blew through all of us.”

Heginbotham wasn’t used to sharing carries when he got to junior high, the first time he and Scherer played on the same team. However, Heginbotham understood why he’d have to balance carries with his former rival, who he said was a short rusher who regularly “bowled through the entire defense.”

Related Article: WPIAL, District 9, District 10 football standings, schedules ahead of Week 5 Related Article: High school football passing, rushing, receiving and scoring leaders in Butler County after Week 4
Karns' City's Hunter Scherer(23) runs through a Brookville defender on a rushing attempt in a football game Friday, Aug. 29, 2025, at Karns City High School. Eddie Clancy/Special to the Eagle

Karns City coach Joe Sherwin described his program’s approach as: “When your number’s called, run as hard as you can. One guy does it for a few plays, and then it’s somebody different,” he said.

“Some people key on Owen, and some people key on me,” Scherer said. “It’s not like everyone’s keying on the same person. They don’t know whether they’re gonna have to break down, like, ‘Who’s getting the ball?’”

Heginbotham doesn’t mind the rest that comes with the timeshare. He also feels relieved not to have to put the offense on his back, he said.

Or carry a yearbook on his shoulders.

Scherer told Heginbotham in the beginning of the school year he was bored sitting in his extra study hall. Heginbotham convinced him to join the yearbook class, and now the two are trying to find a creative way to put it together. That includes snapping photos.

Related Article: Karns City football routs Moniteau in rivalry rematch as Owen Heginbotham, Hunter Scherer put up big games

“I’m gonna say I’m a beginner level,” Heginbotham said. “I might be a little better than Scherer, though.”

“I don’t really like using a camera,” Scherer said. “I didn’t know I had to use a camera. ... I turned it on today, and I tried to take a picture and (it wouldn’t let me). It was something about the flash.”

Heginbotham, who’d rather take a good picture than get one taken of him, considers himself to be the speedy tailback while Scherer is “the heavy hitter.” The latter felt the former was shortchanging his style.

“He has the mentality ... that he’s gonna put his head right through you and drag you,” Scherer said of Heginbotham.

As for their photo-taking skills?

“I think they’d better maybe look for another line of work,” Sherwin said, laughing.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS