Site last updated: Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Aluminum shop keeps past alive

GROVE CITY - Broken windows scar the little shop in the alley. Vines blanket the walls, as if to combat the chill that infiltrates through missing panes.

On the outside, time has taken its toll.

But inside, Arthur Armour's workshop looks just as it did during The Great Depression, when the craftsman made his mark on sheets of aluminum and also on the borough's history.

History continues to emerge as Armour's sons, Tom and David, document their late father's career as templates, sketches and other elements of the decorative hammered aluminum craft surface in the cluttered shop.

"I didn't realize, really, my dad was such a packrat," said David recently, as he and his brother poked through the building's mysterious contents.

With a doctorate degree in colonial history, David recently returned to Grove City after retiring from his 35-year post as deputy director of Mackinaw Island State Park Commission.

As part of his retirement, David will help his brother, a retired obstetrician who now serves as director of the Grove City Historical Society, document the items in the shop and preserve the chronology of Armour's career, which began in the early 1930s.

An architect by trade, Armour worked for six months as a designer for Wendell August, who lost many of his assets except the forge after the stock market crashed in 1929.At that time, aluminum was the new wonder metal, Tom explained, so the decorative pieces crafted by August appealed to many elite shoppers.Many attribute the craft's growth in Western Pennsylvania to Alcoa, the Aluminum Company of America, which in the late 1920s contracted with Wendell August to make decorative gates for its research laboratories east of Pittsburgh.

In the fall of 1932, Armour began working for Wendell August as a designer. His training as an architect provided him with artistry skills that some workers lacked, Tom said. So when Armour was laid off six months later, he took his knack for design and launched his own business."As I recall, he borrowed $300 from his mother," said Tom. "He bought that steel block and carved the (Ducks in Flight tray) pattern ... $300 was the most he was ever in debt.""He sat on the porch and carved the die," Tom went on, pointing to a house across the alley where his grandparents had lived. "Steel was his canvas. His tools were chisels."He always said, 'All I sell is hammer marks,'" Tom recalled, later explaining how Armour had secured his first orders by teaming up with a wholesale distributor in New York."He took the tray to the Chicago Gift Show in the Palmer House hotel. He knew he could make (the trays) but he didn't think he could sell them. So he went to Chicago to try to find a salesman to represent him," Tom went on, explaining how Armour formed a relationship with sales representative A. Stanley Brussel.

"The best years of the industry were 1933 to 1941," David added. "It all hinges on the Depression. A lot of people were out of work. So my father could hire people cheap. This was a handcraft business. But there were still people who had money and bought (the hammered-aluminum wares). It was that kind of disconnect between top and bottom that made this work."Maintaining the same atmosphere it possessed while in use, Armour's shop reflects a mindset typical of the Depression. Since the economy was so tentative, Armour's sons say he was hesitant to invest in anything not essential to day-to-day production.The tools and supplies stacked randomly around the building confirm the temporary attitude with which his son's say Armour approached his work."He always though it was going to collapse," said David about his father's distrust of long-term investment in the business.

"My dad wasn't trying to puff himself up," David added of his father's unassuming workspace, recounting something his father had said of the shop: "All I was trying to do was put food on the table."But when one looks at the intricate designs on the bowls, trays and other ornamental objects he created, it's hard to believe Armour was thinking strictly of utility.Georgie Hodge of Grove City, who with her husband, Jeff, has been collecting hammered aluminum for about 15 years, said Armour's designs are highly regarded by collectors."There are probably 15 to 30 names that are collected," Hodge said. "Arthur Armor is probably one of the two most sought collectible names in the business."Hodge said she and her husband can recognize Armour's work and that of different craftsmen before seeing their distinct signatures on the pieces."A trained eye can tell from a room away," she said. "You can tell."Hodge said like Armour, most of the noted craftsmen began by working with Wendell August, eventually breaking away to market their own products.In addition to style, Armour is also noted for his anodized pieces, whose colored finishes cause the aluminum to resemble bronze or gold.

Jimmy Vincent, 83, of Grove City, recalls how Armour began marketing the anodized pieces after the war, when aluminum's newness began to wane.Vincent said he met Armour at age 12 or 13, when he would peer in the doors of Armour's workshop. When he was hired by Armour several years later, Vincent said he began by flattening the aluminum after the repoussé process, then later was assigned the delicate job of coloring.Vincent said finish on the anodized pieces was prepared in Ohio, and, with the exception of some goblets he had once seen marketed, the products were unique to Armour."I don't recall ever seeing any other than just ours," he said."There's a lot of spin-off, I suppose. Men that had worked for Wendell August went off and started making aluminum on their own. This set ours apart from the rest of them."In the 1940s, Vincent was drafted into the Army, causing a lapse in his work at Armour's shop.During World War II, production slowed."The war came," Tom said. "And shut everybody down. It took all the aluminum."By the 1950s, fascination with the novelty metal had begun to fade as the market became saturated with aluminum products.Despite this, Armour continued to do business, employing as many as 30 people in his shop until the 1970s, when he retired."We were working and he was running out of metal," Vincent recalled, explaining Armour needed to order a three-year supply of metal in order to get a good price. "I think he must have been 75, and he just decided he didn't want to work until he was 80."He just used up the metal he had and shut the door," Vincent said, adding the staff was warned well in advance the shop would close. Armour continued to tinker in the shop after retiring, Vincent added.Since Armour's death in 1998, the shop has remained intact. Sketches and notes cover surfaces. Tools sit on benches, as if they were used just moments earlier. The calendar reads 1976, the year production stopped.Too small and out-of-the-way to be marketed as a museum, the stone shop continues to sit unnoticed - a part of the past preserved inside.

More in Community

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS