Site last updated: Thursday, September 11, 2025

Log In

Reset Password
MENU
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Best Insurance Agency

Best Insurance Agency is an independent representing many financially stable companies including Donegal Group, Encompass Personal Insurance, Westfield Group, Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield, AFLAC, UPMC Health Plan, HealthAmerica and Merchants Insurance Group.

These high quality companies, combined with our knowledgeable and experienced staff, provide the Butler region with an excellent option for all your insurance needs.

Our business insurance department has the expertise to analyze your business insurance needs, including surety bonds, and place coverage at competitive prices. Whether your business is large or small, our commercial insurance department will provide the service you deserve.

While other agencies may provide personal and some commercial insurance products, Best Insurance Agency has an extensive and experienced health and life insurance department specializing in group and individual health plans, including health savings accounts.

Representing all of the major health insurance carriers allows us to provide a variety of proposals with alternate plans and premium levels.

Since 1917, Best Insurance Agency has been proud to advise and service the region's insurance needs from downtown Butler.

Helping you wade through the often confusing insurance buying process in a friendly relaxed atmosphere are Jamie McDonald, Michelle Warner, Carol Prokay, Katie Johnson and Debbie Young. Our sales staff of Tom Fleming, Cathy Berger-Reese and Jeff Sinz are available to review and provide competitive premium quotes, be it in-person, over the phone or via e-mail.

The agency principals, Carol and Rick McClean, Ray Rosenbauer, Mike Reese and Don Best thank the Butler area for almost 90 years of success and stability. We invite you to visit our web site: www.bestinsurancebutler.com, call at 724-283-5670 or 1-888-BEST-INS or stop by the office at 340 S. Main St. across from the Butler Post Office.

More in Special Sections

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS