Risky Business
MILWAUKEE — A Wisconsin lawmaker who included a misstatement on his official biography suffered embarrassment and frustration when the embellishment came to light, but employment experts warn that such a slip by a job applicant could be even more disastrous.
State Rep. Terry Musser recently clarified that he did not serve as a Green Beret, although between two tours of duty in Vietnam, he wore the green beret as part of his uniform while serving with the 6th Special Forces at Fort Bragg, N.C.
"Hindsight, I should have put down Signal Company, 6th Special Forces, Fort Bragg, and let it go," Musser said. "But then one of the reasons I went further is most people say, 'What the hell is the 6th Special Forces?"'
After a Missouri-based advocacy group challenged Musser's reference to the Green Beret in his official biography, Musser, a Republican, issued a clarification.
Good way to never get a job
Now he hopes others learn from his experience.
"Unless you're trying to lie to people, don't try to embellish your record. I mean, you have to put it out there and let people decide at face value," Musser said.
Cases such as Musser's show the premium that jobseekers must put on clarity in their resumes, experts say.
"I think what you put in a resume absolutely has to be rock-solid, concrete verifiable, that if there is any question, that it will immediately throw both your application and your credibility into question," said Dennis Reina, an organizational psychologist and co-author of the book "Trust & Betrayal in the Workplace."
"I can't believe that people, especially with the vast resources that are available at the fingertip, would still go out — and I don't mean this in Musser's case — and stretch, falsify, make a false claim, however you'd want to phrase it, something on a resume. It's a surefire way to never get a job, once it's discovered," said Evan Zeppos, president of a Milwaukee public relations firm.
"Hopefully, if it's still going on, it's in a small minority of people who stay unemployed, because you don't want someone like that in any organization," Zeppos said.
Betrayal begets betrayal
Jude Werra, an executive placement specialist in Brookfield, Wis., catches about 10 percent of job candidates misrepresenting their credentials. Since 1995, Werra has published a twice-yearly Liars Index, measuring the degree to which executives embellish their academic achievements.
"It is relatively consistent that people continue to do it," said Werra, who reviews between 200 and 300 resumes a year. "It's kind of unclear why an individual would misrepresent that when it's so easy to check."
Generally, people who feel they need to exaggerate their experience tend to think they can't be accepted for who they are, said Reina, who's based in Vermont and includes among his clients such organizations as Kimberly-Clark Corp. Such lack of trust in themselves can make people less trustworthy to others.
"Trust begets trust, and betrayal begets betrayal," Reina said. "And betrayal is a breach of trust or the perception of a breach." Perception is part of the equation, Reina asserted, because there's a heightened sensitivity to whether someone should be trusted.
"I think there's a real phenomenon out there these days that we tend to be quick to judge, quick to make assumptions, jump to conclusions and point the finger in blame," Reina said.
Labor market conditions also might have some effect on resume fudging.
Richard Coughlan, an authority on business ethics and associate dean for graduate business programs at the University of Richmond in Virginia, says stiff competition can motivate job candidates to be more "creative" in presenting their qualifications. Werra said tight hiring markets can tempt employers to overlook due diligence on applicants.
But employers also are at fault for not doing more to keep applicants honest, Werra said.
"It doesn't help the employer not to verify," Werra said. "You know, it's the old Reagan quote: 'Trust but verify.' It behooves employers to do the verification."
Damage can be lasting
For his part, Musser said he has been careful to state other aspects of his background — for instance, making a point of saying he "attended UW-La Crosse" from 1973 to 1976 rather than claiming he had graduated from there.
"I always dotted the i's and crossed the t's on stuff like that, but it's like this one I got lackadaisical on," Musser said of his Green Beret reference. "I guess that's what's frustrating to me is, why the hell did I? But again, hindsight's 20-20."
The worst part, Musser said, is what the publicity has done to his reputation.
"Number one, it overshadows 20 years working for veterans. To some people, that's forgotten," said Musser, who's chairman of the Assembly Committee on Veterans and Military Affairs. "That's not worth it because then it calls into question what you did or what you're trying to do for a group of people.
"That, to me, is the hardest part to overcome."
The bottom line for jobseekers, Zeppos said, is to be clear and truthful both in representing yourself and in correcting misperceptions.
"Even though it's a very brutal workplace everywhere," Zeppos said, "we still live in a very forgiving society — if you're honest and straightforward."
Experts warn jobseekers to watch these potential trouble spots on resumes:• Education: Be clear and accurate on degrees earned and years and schools attended.• Chronology: Honestly explain gaps in relevant work experience. Beware of overlapping employment dates. Don't stretch dates to conceal brevity.• Experience: Don't fabricate job titles.• Accomplishments: Use strong action verbs and specific examples — but don't exaggerate.• References: If you offer people who would vouch for you, clear it with them first.• Associations: If you're not currently a member, say so.Sources: University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee Career Development Center; Marquette University Career Services Center; Manpower Inc.
