Site last updated: Monday, November 16, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Officials answer questions on potential BASA sale

Local landlord Jeff Weber, left, talks with Sean Graves of Pennsylvania American Water Company on Tuesday, Sept. 27, at an open house at St. Peter's Catholic Church social hall. Four open houses are being held so BASA customers can share questions and concerns on the potential sale of the sewer authority to the water company. Shane Potter/Butler Eagle

If any customer of Butler Area Sewer Authority has questions about the authority’s potential sale to Pennsylvania American Water Company, now is the time to ask.

On Tuesday, about a dozen Pennsylvania American officials, several BASA employees and board members, plus people from its public relations firm, community-group leaders, and elected officials from both Butler and Butler Township were at the first of four open houses planned for this week.

The open houses were devised to hear questions and concerns from customers regarding the $231.5 million potential sale of the sewer authority to the private company.

The initial open house was from 10 a.m. to noon at St. Peter Catholic Church social hall in Butler.

People who attended learned about the authority’s list of improvement projects, totaling nearly $76 million.

Butler Mayor Bob Dandoy said the repairs likely would take BASA 20 to 25 years to complete, while Pennsylvania American must have the work done within five years, according to the potential sale contract.

He added that people who approached his table did not ask about the competency of BASA or Pennsylvania American, the repairs needed at the sewer plant or infrastructure, or any subject other than the potential for rate increases if the authority is taken over by the water company.

Dandoy said that because of the many improvements needed, rates will definitely increase even if BASA does not sell to Pennsylvania American.

“We have certainly considered those rate increases,” he said.

Willie Adams, a Summit Township supervisor, visited the open house to discuss his contention that the municipalities with BASA customers should get a share of the potential sale’s proceeds instead of the money being split between Butler and Butler Township only, which BASA has determined are the sewer system’s sole owners.

Adams also apprised Pennsylvania American officials of Summit Township’s sewer dilemma, as decades of failing on-lot septic systems have resulted in a mandate by the state Department of Environmental Protection that the rural township build a sewer plant.

Adams said Summit supervisors asked BASA to accept and process sewer from the township, but BASA would require Summit to pay for the upgraded pipes to the plant.

Summit abandoned the idea because of that expense, but Adams came to the open house to approach Pennsylvania American about processing sewage from Summit Township.

Adams said 2.1% of BASA’s customers are in Summit Township, which would equate to a payment of about $5 million if profits from the sale are split among municipalities with customers.

That would make a down payment on the estimated $24.2 million construction of a sewer plant in Summit Township, Adams said.

“We have skin in the game, and we should share in the $231.5 million,” he said.

Also attending the open house Tuesday morning were a pair of landlords who own rental housing serviced by BASA.

Jeff Weber owns 56 units, all of which are serviced by BASA. Shaun Brown has 37 rentals on the BASA system.

Weber said because sewer bills would be based on water use under Pennsylvania American, the cost for that utility would be paid by tenants instead of by him.

Currently, if a tenant experiences a sewer issue, Weber takes care of it as the BASA account holder.

If Pennsylvania American buys the sewer authority, Weber said, tenants would call the company if they experience a leak or other problem.

“We are trying to protect our tenants from this,” Weber said of the potential sale.

Regarding the argument that the Pennsylvania Utilities Commission must approve all rate increases, Weber said he was made aware that people testifying in a rate increase hearing must incur the expenses of hiring an attorney and traveling to Harrisburg to testify.

Weber also surmises that the commission does not place a limit on rate increases, as it recently approved a 44% increase in electricity rates.

Brown agreed with Weber’s analysis of the situation.

“The tenants are going to be the ones who get hit the hardest by (the sale),” he said.

He added that most of his rentals are occupied by multiple people in one unit, so he worries about bills being based on water usage.

Both landlords agreed that it would be less expensive for a public entity such as the sewer authority to repair infrastructure and equipment, as a public company pays sales tax on parts and equipment, real estate tax on buildings and taxes on capital gains.

“That is essentially all rolled into the rates the end customer is going to have to pay,” Brown said.

A combined 25 people attended the two meetings on Tuesday at St. Peter.

Sewer sale open houses


The next opportunity for the public to share concerns or ask questions about the potential sale of the Butler Area Sewer Authority to Pennsylvania American Water Company is at two open houses on Thursday: the first from 10 a.m. to noon and the second from 6 to 8 p.m. Both are being held at the Butler Township building at the intersection of Whitestown and South Duffy roads.

BASA serves almost 15,000 residential and commercial customers over 32.5 miles in Butler, Butler Township, Center Township and East Butler plus parts of Summit, Penn and Oakland townships and Connoquenessing borough.

More in

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS