Site last updated: Monday, April 20, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
MENU
Butler County's great daily newspaper

President's proposed ban on flavored vaping an overreaction

I make it a point not to comment too much or too often on the actions of the Trump administration, because there is no shortage of ink spent on those activities already and who has that kind of time or stamina anyway? But here’s something that perplexes me a bit, coming from an administration that both friends and foes call “conservative”: the proposed ban of flavored e-cigarettes.

To be fair, the proposal is a response to what some hyperbolic media reports have characterized as a public health crisis - a small number of severe lung illnesses, several tragically resulting in death, associated with the use of vaping devices.

Many of these cases involve teenagers like 17-year-old Whitney Livingston of Dallas, who had a history of vaping and was put on life support earlier this month. “She could have almost died,” her mother told Fox 4 News after Livingston suddenly developed pneumonia in both lungs.

Livingston is only one of 17 vaping-related cases reported to health officials in Dallas County.

In Tarrant County, there are eight reported cases of lung illness believed to have been caused by vaping, although the ages of those involved have not been released.

Nationwide, the number of vaping-related lung illnesses has reached 530 (as of Sept. 17), with cases reported in 38 states and one U.S. territory and seven deaths in six states attributed to vaping.

Sixteen percent of vaping illnesses have involved individuals under 18 years of age, and those cases specifically - involving what appear to be otherwise healthy youth - motivated the administration to take some action.

Federal health officials believe that clearing the market of flavored e-cigarettes will reverse the epidemic of e-cigarette use, a questionable notion. Even so, Secretary of Health and Human Services Alex Azar has called the proliferation of youth vaping “deeply concerning.”

I wouldn’t disagree with him there. I, for one, was disturbed when a vape store opened across the street from Paschal High School. It promptly closed, but the location was obviously chosen to target high school kids.

Indeed, vaping has risen sharply among high schoolers in the last several years; nearly 21 percent of high school students said they vaped between 2017 and 2018.

That’s because while vaping has helped millions of people kick their smoking habit and generally has been viewed as a safe alternative to smoking, it’s also attracted new clientele in the form of young people who never smoked traditional cigarettes. And like their combustible cousins, e-cigarettes contain the addictive substance nicotine.

So it’s a safe bet that nicotine, not cotton-candy flavor, vaping is what keeps teenagers vaping, but I digress. Addiction, especially among the young, generally isn’t a good thing.

And there is a lot we don’t know about vaping and its impact on long-term health. That research should continue.

Cynthia M. Allen is a columnist for the Fort Worth Star-Telegram.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS