Site last updated: Friday, January 9, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
MENU
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Biggest surprises of girls basketball season thus far? Butler’s Emily Hoffer, Karns City’s youth movement, more

It’s getting to the point in the high school girls basketball season where teams are clear on what their identity is. Some Butler County squads have seen players step up, while others have shown promise to do so.

Here are some mostly unheralded surprises that local teams are happy about.

Better late than never for Butler’s Hoffer
Butler's Emily Hoffer (23) looks to pass against Avonworth in a girls basketball game Monday, Dec. 29, 2025, at Butler High School. JJ LaBella/Special to the Eagle

As a junior, Emily Hoffer didn’t get much time on the floor for the Golden Tornado. Now a senior, she’s been, as Butler coach Mark Maier put it, “a revelation.”

“The epitome of a high school player who stuck it out and didn’t play any meaningful varsity minutes until her senior year,” Maier said. “Great story to learn from.”

Hoffer averaged nine points and six boards through her team’s first dozen matchups. She plays bigger than her 5-foot-8 stature, too.

“She’s guarded the other teams’ big girl to shooting guard and does a really good job of playing positional defense and not fouling,” Maier said.

Related Article: Malina McElroy, Butler girls basketball swipe win from Moon to sweep holiday tournament
Ewing going above and beyond for Knights’ girls
Knoch's Neah Ewing (11) looks for an opening in a girls basketball game Thursday, Jan. 30, 2025, at Knoch High School. Ralph LoVuolo/Special to the Eagle

Knoch hasn’t gotten off to the start it was hoping for, but if Neah Ewing’s efforts lately are any indication, the latter half of the season will be more enjoyable than the former.

“We expected her to lead us in scoring, but this is more than expected,” Knights coach Shane McGraw said. “She is heating up and leading our offense.”

During a five-game stretch that started in mid-December and ended with Knoch’s first win of the campaign — a 57-26 triumph over Derry on Monday — Ewing averaged 17 points per game. That included 18 against Redbank Valley, 22 against Karns City and 26 in the victory over the Trojans.

Gremlins girls enjoying youth movement
Karns City’s Alivia Farren (5) takes a shot against Moniteau in a girls basketball game Friday, Dec. 5, 2025, at Moniteau High School. JJ LaBella/Special to the Eagle

Coach Steve Andreassi’s Karns City group started 8-1, thanks in large part to freshmen Taylor Ritzert, Audrey Heginbotham and Josie Emrick and sophomores Alivia Farren and Maddie Mahood.

“The underclassmen have been key to our early success,” Andreassi said.

Supporting cast aiding Rockets’ cause in big way
Slippery Rock's Brielle Jordan (10) passes the ball against Oakland Catholic in the first round of the PIAA Class 4A girls basketball tournament Saturday, March 8, 2025, at Oakland Catholic High School. Jared Todhunter/Special to the Eagle

Slippery Rock girls coach Jeff Steele has three targets for his team to aim for each outing — rebound half of its missed shots, get 70 possessions per game and bucket 51 points.

“We are 21-3 the last two years when we score 51 points,” Steele said.

Rockets junior point guard Brielle Jordan has been doing more than her fair share to help attain such goals. Sophomore Gia Kovacik is nearly averaging a double-double, and Vanessa Hinkle is “playing as efficiently as anyone and attacking the offensive glass,” Steele said.

Slippery Rock got off to a 7-3 start.

2 unknowns shedding label for North Catholic girls
North Catholic’s Maggie Tatar (23) passes against Seneca Valley in a girls basketball game Thursday, Dec. 4, 2025, at Seneca Valley High School. JJ LaBella/Special to the Eagle

Fans wouldn’t have heard junior Maggie Tatar’s name going to a Trojanettes game last season. Freshman Finley O’Shea, either.

Not now.

Tatar has taken over at point guard for coach Molly Rottmann’s squad, which started 7-3, and is regularly guarding the other side’s best player. O’Shea started on the bench this season but has become a starter due to injuries ahead of her.

“She has been our leading rebounder some games and is second on our team in rebounds,” Rottmann said of O’Shea.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS