Site last updated: Tuesday, August 19, 2025

Log In

Reset Password
MENU
Butler County's great daily newspaper

High school football preseason Sweet 16: Meet the top Butler County players on defense in 2025

Butler's Nicco Baggetta will start at quarterback and linebacker this year. He had 36 tackles and two interceptions in 2024 on defense. Jared Todhunter/Special to the Eagle

Football offenses get most of the headlines, but defenses can play just as much of a role in victory or defeat.

This season, Butler County-area teams return established leaders and players on the cusp of becoming stars at all three levels.

From stuffing the run and rushing the passer to breaking up passes and snagging game-changing interceptions, here are the players the Butler Eagle expects to shine the brightest this fall. It’s the Preseason Sweet 16 Defense, listed alphabetically:

Related Article: High school football preseason Sweet 16: Meet the top Butler County players on offense in 2025 Related Article: PA high school football 2025: Butler County team previews, top players and fall sports breakdowns
Nicco Baggetta, jr. QB/LB, Butler

He tallied 36 tackles and two interceptions as a sophomore. Had a memorable spring throwing the javelin and brings great athleticism to Butler’s defense.

Karns City’s Mason Bell. Butler Eagle file photo
Mason Bell, sr., OL/DL, Karns City

A veteran of KC’s defensive front, he tallied 10 sacks a year ago, giving him 25 for his varsity career.

Knoch’s Carter Beres had 59 tackles last season as a sophomore linebacker. Butler Eagle file photo
Carter Beres, jr., RB/LB, Knoch

Seems primed to spur Knoch’s resurgence after a solid sophomore campaign that included 59 tackles, including nine for a loss, and an interception.

Butler’s Beau Burchett during the Butler Eagle Football Media Day on Friday, Aug. 1, 2025, at Butler High School. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Beau Burchett, sr., OL/DL, Butler

Nine of his 31 tackles last year came behind the line of scrimmage. Appears physically and mentally ready to lead the defense as a senior. Burchett is receiving some college interest as a defensive lineman, head coach Eric Christy said.

Mars’ Zach Dentel during Butler Eagle Football Media Day on Friday, Aug. 1, 2025, at Butler High School. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Zach Dentel, sr., RB/LB, Mars

He has a nose for the football, evidenced by his team-leading 99 tackles and three interceptions during his junior season.

Union/A-C Valley’s Colbin Elliott during the Butler Eagle Football Media Day on Friday, Aug. 1, 2025, at Butler High School. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Colbin Elliott, sr., OL/DL, Union/A-C Valley

The leader of the Falcon Knights’ front on both sides of the ball, he moves from outside linebacker to the line this season. Made 90 tackles as a junior. He holds Division III offers from Westminster and Thiel.

Karns City's Shane Emrick (50) led the Gremlins’ defense last year with 62 tackles. Butler Eagle file photo
Shane Emrick, jr., OL/LB, Karns City

He may earn a starting spot on the offensive line this season, but either way, he returns on defense where he led the team in tackles last year with 62.

Related Article: 2025 Butler Eagle Scoring Trophy watch list: Who are the contenders to take home this year’s award?
Union/A-C Valley's Aidan Fox had 61 tackles and three interceptions a year ago. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle
Aidan Fox, sr., WR/DB, Union/A-C Valley

His speed will have a major influence on offense and defense as a safety. Made 61 tackles and picked off three passes in 2024.

North Catholic’s Nick Franco during the Butler Eagle Football Media Day on Friday, Aug. 1, 2025, at Butler High School. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Nick Franco, sr., TE/LB, North Catholic

A key source of physicality on North’s defense, he may be used as an H-back on offense. Has received offers from Allegheny College and John Carroll.

Freeport’s Dawson Gaillot had 120 tackles last year and will be the focal point of the Yellowjackets’ defense once again. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Dawson Gaillot, sr., RB/LB, Freeport

He’s one of the reasons the Yellowjackets are thinking big in 2025. The “quarterback” of the defense, he made 120 tackles as a junior.

Union/A-C Valley’s Max Gallagher during the Butler Eagle Football Media Day on Friday, Aug. 1, 2025, at Butler High School. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Max Gallagher, sr., RB/LB, Union/A-C Valley

You’d be hard pressed to find a player who means more to his team than Gallagher. A dual threat at running back, he had 118 tackles on defense in 2024, 75 of them solo.

Mars’ Ethan Kresinski. Morgan Phillips/Butler Eagle
Ethan Kresinski, sr., TE/DL, Mars

After playing well last year at linebacker, he will make the move to defensive end for a stout Planets defense.

Seneca Valley's Cayden Parker (4) will move from edge to middle linebacker this season. He’s receiving Division I interest as well. Butler Eagle file photo
Cayden Parker, sr., RB/LB, Seneca Valley

He was an edge rusher last year, but will be at middle linebacker in 2025. Is being recruited by the University of Buffalo, James Madison, Miami (Ohio) and Toledo.

Wade Potocnak, sr., OL/DL, Freeport

A mainstay on the offensive and defensive fronts, his ability was displayed last year with 76 tackles, four sacks and four interceptions.

Slippery Rock’s Jacob Reich during the Butler Eagle Football Media Day on Friday, Aug. 1, 2025, at Butler High School. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Jacob Reich, sr., OL/DL, Slippery Rock

Will be starting for the third straight year and can play multiple positions on both lines. Is the unquestioned leader for the Rockets.

Related Article: PA high school football 2025: Top 10 games you don’t want to miss in Butler County this season
Freeport's Cole Troutman is the other half of a the Yellowjackets’ two top returning defenders after he had six sacks a year ago. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Cole Troutman, sr., OL/DL, Freeport

He’s a disruptive force, making 107 tackles, including six sacks, last year. Also a leader on the team’s offensive line.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS