Site last updated: Thursday, September 10, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Metcalfe bill would prevent denial of care over vaccines

Critics warn of outbreaks

HARRISBURG — State Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, R-12th, was joined by dozens of children and their families Tuesday to introduce a bill that aims to stop denial of medical care for those who decline or delay vaccinations.

House Bill 286, the Pennsylvania Vaccine Informed Consent Protection Act, would prohibit pediatricians from denying care and “other forms of discrimination” against patients, parents and guardians who choose to opt out of or alter a vaccination schedule.

Metcalfe pointed to those assembled around him who had been injured or had adverse reactions to vaccinations as the main beneficiaries of the bill. He said it ensures that children still have access to care when their parents use due diligence in making decisions about vaccinations.

“It's a parent's right to make that decision for their child,” he said. “Our children don't belong to the state. This is not Communist Russia. This is the United States of America, and under our Constitution, the God-given rights that have been declared, you should enjoy your freedom, and you should enjoy that freedom to decide for your children what is in their best interest.”

The bill also prohibits insurance companies from making families pay more for care or sign liability waivers if they choose not to follow vaccination suggestions. Metcalfe was clear in stating the bill is not about the value of vaccines.

“This isn't about whether or not vaccines are good or bad,” he said. “This is about making sure that children are having the best decisions for their health made by their parents, that their access to health care that their parents are searching for on their behalf isn't interfered with by organizations.”

Metcalfe said vaccines can cause injury, and they are often pushed on parents in a way that can be intimidating. He said insurance companies provide kickbacks to doctors who push vaccinations and allow that to be a deciding factor for health practices.

“I think it is fully unethical for a doctor to get a kickback for how many kids are being vaccinated at their practice,” he said.

Metcalfe was joined by medical professionals and legal experts, including Dr. Alvin Moss, who said the relationship between a doctor and patient has evolved, and is no longer about a doctor making medical decisions for their patients. Moss, who is a professor of medicine at West Virginia University and has testified as an expert witness on vaccines before the West Virginia legislature, said the decisions should continue to be made by patients after they are provided with information from the doctor.

“Informed consent, to be true consent, needs to be voluntary, not coerced and without manipulation, and it needs to discuss the risks,” he said. “House Bill 286 is a remedy to ... the unethical assault on informed consent and patient and family centered care.”

James Lyons-Weiler said recent information sent by the American Academy of Pediatrics to President Donald Trump included studies indicating vaccines don't cause autism and other issues. However, he said the organization “committed fraud” by not including all studies, and that those sent were lacking data from specific test groups. Lyons-Weiler, a research scientist and president and CEO of The Institute for Pure and Applied Knowledge, said those assembled are proof that vaccines carry risks.

Critics of the bill, including Rep. Dan Frankel, D-23rd who serves as chairman of the House Health Committee, pointed to a recent increase in the number of measles cases as a reason vaccines are needed.

“Today across the United States, communities find themselves confronting outbreaks of diseases that we had successfully eradicated decades ago,” Frankel said. “These outbreaks are occurring not because the disease changed or mutated, but because people chose to forgo safe, effective vaccinations, putting themselves or their children at risk.”

He added that Metcalfe is “lending the dignity of his office to the pseudo-science of the antivaccination community” by sponsoring the bill, which he called “irresponsible.”

According to Frankel, as of Monday there had been 13 individual outbreaks of measles in 22 states this year, affecting more than 700 individuals. More than 500 of those infected were not vaccinated.

Metcalfe downplayed the severity of the situation.

“There are 300 million people in the United States of America,” he said. “Look at some of the car accident rates and people dying from running into a white tail deer, and compare that to the number of people contracting measles, that isn't generally a life-threatening disease.”

Lyons-Weiler said measles naturally cycles every three to four years, with most cases coming from outside the United States. The transmissions run their course and then are done, he said. Moss said the discussion on measles is an example of the idea of vaccines being imposed on Americans.

“We're being manipulated by people who make money selling vaccines,” he said.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS