Job evaluations might unnerve new managers
There's a first time for everything — and that includes the day you switch from being the recipient of a performance review to being the person who delivers it.
To help the person in the new role as supervisor, Diane Arthur, president of Arthur Associates Management Consultants, a human resources firm in Northport, N.Y., wrote "The First-Time Manager's Guide to Performance Appraisals" (Amacom Books, $15). She includes sample dialogues, words and phrases, and ways to prepare for the meeting with an employee.
Here is some advice from Arthur and others for those new to evaluating employees.
• How tough? Most important, Arthur says, is that you don't fall into the trap of trying to come across as "tougher and more authoritative" than is necessary. Sometimes, newbies do that in the hopes they'll be taken more seriously. Confidence is great, she says, but not "strutting."
• Keep the tone collaborative. Don't say, "You must stop that." Instead, she says, try something like, "Please tell me how you plan to rectify this." "Don't 'should' them," says Paul Baard, a communications and management professor at Fordham University. Instead, point out the employee "would be well served by using a time management system." The idea, he says, is to focus on behaviors, "build the person up," not attack character.
• Back it up. Have data to support your statements. Sherrie Brouillard was promoted last fall to supervisor in the collections department at People's Alliance Federal Credit Union in Hauppauge, N.Y.; since then, she has kept notes that helped her complete evaluations for seven staffers who report to her. She says she's learned it's important to give feedback during the year so an employee is not surprised by anything said in the review.
• When the employee is a buddy (or former buddy). Yes, Arthur says, this can be awkward. And her advice, if it seems appropriate, is to acknowledge the situation by saying, "I know this may feel a little awkward for both of us." If you get guff from the person you're reviewing — along the lines of, "I liked you better before," say something like: "Things do change. But, you're still my colleague, and I'm glad you are," Baard says.
• When the employee is significantly older. Acknowledge the person's experience. And be thankful you're not in this situation that Arthur describes: A young man in a seminar she was conducting told of working for a manufacturing company alongside his father. The son was promoted, so he was his father's boss — with the job of doing his review. And the father had an attendance problem!
• The employee's response. When the person sitting on the other side of the desk responds with a laundry list of what's wrong with the workplace — or with you — it's a form of venting, Arthur says, and as long as it's kept under control, you need to be able to deal with it. For one thing, it's valuable for employers to find out what's on their employees' minds. And she says she would rather have the employee express dissatisfaction directly to her than do it behind her back.
• The problem employee. Yes, having to review the performance of the office grinch is not something most people rejoice over. But Baard says it's important to remember "even if people are prickly and emotionally overreactive, they are still entitled to candid feedback," or they'll have no idea they need to adjust their work habits.
