Site last updated: Wednesday, October 14, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Couple wins $3M for misdiagnosis

PITTSBURGH — A suburban Pittsburgh couple has won a $3 million malpractice suit after the woman's sinus infection was misdiagnosed and turned into a brain abscess.

Lynn and James Flaherty, of Bethel Park, won the suit this week against doctors Lesley DeGiovanni, John Montini and physician assistant, Kellie Egidi. They plan to appeal.

The Flahertys' attorney says Lynn Flaherty visited their office in 2001, complaining of headaches and nasal discharge.

The doctors were unavailable, and Egidi recommended additional testing and prescribed steroids.

Experts testified steroids without an antibiotic would mask and exacerbate the infection. She remains unable to regulate her emotions and has difficulty with complex cognitive function.

More in Pennsylvania News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS