Smoking ban bill gains traction but faces fight
HARRISBURG — Legislation that would ban smoking in bars, restaurants and other public spaces and work places was endorsed by a state Senate committee Monday, although senators acknowledged that lobbyists are applying heavy pressure to scale it back.
The Senate Appropriations Committee voted unanimously to allow the bill to advance to the floor. At the same time, amendments to allow smoking in places like private clubs, neighborhood taverns and slot-machine casinos were being drafted, and could be debated on the Senate floor as early as this week, senators said.
The bill's sponsor, Sen. Stewart Greenleaf, R-Montgomery, has tried for more than a decade to get such a smoking ban through the Legislature, and said attempts to carve out exemptions ignore the fact that secondhand smoke is considered a carcinogen.
"We're talking about a deadly substance and we can't compromise people's health and lives," Greenleaf said.
Greenleaf said the principal opposition is coming from casinos, tobacco companies and taverns.
Greenleaf's bill would ban smoking in a broad range of public buildings and private businesses, including homes that are used for day care businesses, auditoriums, sports arenas and shopping malls.
Not even slot-machine casinos and bingo halls would be spared from the ban. The only exemptions would apply to tobacco-related businesses, such as cigar shops and tobacco importers, and one-quarter of all rooms in lodging establishments.
The Senate's Republican leader, Dominic Pileggi of Delaware County, said he hopes to hold a floor vote on the bill by the end of June.
A spokesman for Gov. Ed Rendell said the Democrat supports Greenleaf's bill, and will look closely at any efforts to scale it back.
"He doesn't want to see an emasculated piece of legislation," said spokesman Chuck Ardo.
The Pennsylvania Tavern Association was lobbying to exempt its members from a smoking ban, warning that a ban would hurt business at the independently owned neighborhood bars and take away a decision that should rest with the owners.
"We're hopeful that we can get something like that," association vice president Jim Christman said.
Pennsylvania's casino owners also have warned that they could lose customers to gambling destinations in neighboring states.
Greenleaf's legislation is supported by the Pennsylvania Medical Society, which lobbies on behalf of doctors. Most people surveyed by the association want to dine in smoke-free restaurants, and secondhand smoke is dangerous, the society said.
Several similar bills have been introduced in the House of Representatives, including two in recent days.
While the two would extend a ban similar to that in Greenleaf's bill, one would exempt businesses that do not serve people under 18 who are not accompanied by a guardian.
More than 25 other states ban smoking in public, although some of those still allow it in bars and restaurants.
