Site last updated: Monday, November 16, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Profiles changing the way hiring is done

Psychological tests limit applicants

KANSAS CITY, Mo. - Have you heard about the tests that are giving employers "fits"?

Bruce McWilliams, general manager at Lee's Summit Honda, credits a 15-minute pre-employment psychological profile with reducing employee turnover and boosting sales at the car dealership.

Rich Mellor, a loss-prevention adviser and division vice president at Helzberg Diamonds, believes a pre-employment integrity and attitude assessment has improved staff quality and cut inventory shrinkage.

Jennifer Bosshardt, spokeswoman for Sprint says a pre-employment personality test is the efficiency tool the company needs to improve the odds of hiring successful workers in its cellular phone stores.

Pre-employment assessments - designed to predict the likelihood that an applicant will be a good "fit" in the job - are sweeping through the work world.

Used sometimes as a first step to reduce the size of the applicant pool and sometimes as a backup to reinforce or overrule job interviewers' instincts, these computerized or pen-and-pencil tests are gaining favor among employers.

Such testing, designed both for applicant screening and employment development, is believed to be a $400-million-per-year industry.

About 30 percent of all companies use personality tests to help make hiring decisions, according to a survey by Management Recruiters International, and the number is mushrooming.

Among job applicants, the embrace isn't quite as strong.

Rebecca Rose, a 43-year-old Kansas City woman with 12 years of experience as a flight attendant, is sure she has the customer-service skills to be a restaurant server or work in retail sales. But when she's taken pre-employment tests, she's been flummoxed at how to answer some questions.

"One store's test asked if anybody had ever annoyed you to the point that you wanted to sit on them," Rose said. "How do you answer a question like that? Of course some passengers have annoyed me. Did I want to sit on them? Yes. Did I sit on them? Of course not."

Marc, who asked that his last name not be used because he doesn't want his employer to know he's looking for a new job, was stunned when he tried to apply for a job at a Sprint cell phone store and didn't pass the pre-employment assessment.

With a 10-year work history and good performance reviews in a responsible government job, Marc was frustrated that he hit a dead end in the application process before he could "sell" himself in an interview.

But Shawn Lyndon, chief executive officer of ePredix , maker of the test that Marc took, said Marc's rejection was based on lots of data about qualities that are important for the specific job and the characteristics of workers who have been successful in those positions.

"There's psychology involved, but it's also a statistics, a numbers game," said ePredix's chief scientist, Jim Beaty, who holds a doctoral degree in industrial and organizational psychology.

"We're sorting people into those who are most likely to succeed and those who are least likely to succeed based on lots of data about the answers that other people chose and how they later performed on that job," Beaty said.

As more companies turn to pre-employment testing, established vendors and academicians who study the discipline warn against buying testing products from companies that lack the data banks or Ph.D.-level staff to justify their testing results.

Fritz Drasgow, past president of the Society for Industrial and Organizational Psychology, said at the association's national conference in April that the explosion of pre-employment testing "can be boon or boondoggle."

"In any growing area, you get people who aren't reputable," Drasgow said. "There's no licensing or registration in this area. It's really caveat emptor ... buyer beware.

"The purchaser needs to ask for the empirical data to support the product. You need a product that has good statistical analysis and good questions designed by industrial-organizational psychologists."

Charles Handler, a New Orleans-based consultant who helps employers select appropriate assessments, said he knows of at least 150 companies selling pre-employment psychological tests. He's seen steady growth since about 1998.

"About then, the Internet opened up a flood of applications, and employers required the development of systems to handle them all," Handler said. "They couldn't do it by hand anymore."

Handler said he finds that he often needs to direct employers to appropriate assessments.

"The Myers-Briggs test (one of the most widely used psychological "type" tests), for example, shouldn't be used for hiring decisions," Handler said.

Similarly, Ben Dattner, a New York-based consultant, said employers must "subject whatever instrument they buy to empirical scrutiny" by making sure the vendor has the expertise and follow-up data to validate the results.

"Then understand that no test can ever be a fail-safe predictor," Dattner said. "If someone says that, run in the opposite direction."

More in Jobless Figures

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS