Site last updated: Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Suspect waits for attorney

Black
DA may seek death penalty

TIONESTA, Forest County — The Butler man suspected of fatally stabbing his former fiancee and her new boyfriend may eventually be assigned an attorney who is qualified to try a capital case.

However, Forest County District Attorney Elizabeth Ziegler said Monday that no decision has been made if she plans to seek the death penalty for Scott A. Black.

The 38-year-old Black is in the Warren County Jail on two counts each of homicide and aggravated assault.

He is accused of killing Marcelle I. Edwards, 42, and Donald L. Shay, 43, of Leechburg, Armstrong County, who had just moved in with Edwards at her mobile home near Tionesta, state police said.

The April 27 slayings followed repeated threatening text messages left by Black to Edwards, his one-time girlfriend, and to Shay, Edwards' boyfriend of just two months, according to investigators.

Black's preliminary hearing for today is continued until May 14.

District Judge George Gregory approved the delay after Warren-Forest County President Judge Maureen Skerda considered who would represent Black at that hearing.

Black originally applied for public defender representation, but Todd Woodin, Forest County's lone public defender, is not death penalty qualified.

There are no attorneys in Forest or Warren counties eligible to provide death-penalty representation.

Although Ziegler has not decided if she would ask the court to certify it as a capital case, she acknowledged she reviewed with Skerda if Black should have a death penalty qualified attorney for his preliminary hearing.

Skerda on Monday determined a public defender, probably Woodin, would serve as Black's counsel at next week's hearing.

In Pennsylvania, a district attorney usually files a notice of intent to seek the death penalty at the defendant's formal arraignment — normally weeks after a preliminary hearing.

To seek the death penalty, the prosecution must prove at least one of 18 possible aggravating circumstances.

One of those aggravating circumstances is if more than one person was murdered.

Investigators suspect Black, possibly motivated by jealousy, began sending threatening texts to Edwards and Shay in the days leading up to the killings.

Black and Edwards had a longtime romantic relationship that ended not long after she began sending out wedding invitations in late December 2012, friends and co-workers said.

Edwards and Shay began seeing one another in February.

Police said Black about 10:35 p.m. April 26 showed up uninvited to Edward's mobile home on Holly Acres Road in Green Township, about seven miles east of Tionesta.

A short time later, Black left in his pickup truck and Shay called police to report a case of assault and harassment against Black.

Troopers got to the home just after midnight.

“Shay showed (police) his cell phone which contained numerous threatening text messages from Scott Black,” according to court documents.

The troopers could not find Black. They left. But within the hour, Black was back.

Edwards' 15-year-old daughter told investigators that she was sleeping on the living room couch when she awoke to find Shay “struggling with” Black, police said.

The girl said when Black hit her mother, she stepped in and hit Black, causing him to fall to the floor.

When the suspect got up and approached the girl, Shay stopped him.

The girl noted that she saw Black holding a “black handled knife with a curved blade,” documents said.

She told police she ran out of the house and dashed to her grandmother's house nearby. The grandmother, who is Edwards' mother, called 911 at 1:11 a.m.

Troopers got to Edwards' home at 1:21 a.m. They found Shay and Edwards dead. Black was gone.

An autopsy found Shay died of multiple stab wounds. Edwards died of a single stab wound.

District Judge George Gregory issued an arrest warrant for Black, who was the target of an extensive manhunt.

Hours later, troopers captured Black when they spotted him in neighboring Kingsley Township, not far from where he kept a pop-up camper trailer.

Gregory also issued police a series of warrants to allow them to search Edwards' home, and Black's camper, truck and clothing.

Troopers sought the warrants to find trace evidence including DNA, blood, hair and fibers.

They also were looking for knives or “cutting tools,” documents said, that could have been used in the killings.

Authorities have not said if they recovered the suspected murder weapon or weapons.

Police last week got court approval to take a DNA sample from Black. That sample could be used to compare with any DNA evidence collected in the criminal investigation.

Butler County court records show Black has two children, ages 18 and 19. He is divorced from their mother.

Less than two years into their marriage, his then-wife got an emergency protection from abuse order against him, according to records.

Three weeks later, they asked the court to dismiss the protective order.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS