Site last updated: Friday, November 20, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Tenants escape injury in early morning blaze

The top floor and roof of this home at 415 E. Brady St. were damaged by a fire early this morning that fire officials said started hours after the home was struck by lightning.
Lightning likely cause of city fire

Butler police early this morning helped nine tenants evacuate a three-story rental home that caught fire hours after it was struck by lightning.

No one was injured in the blaze that erupted as the occupants were asleep just before 3 a.m. at 415 E. Brady St., fire officials said, but the top floor and roof were badly damaged.

Butler Fire Chief Nick Ban said the fire remains under investigation, but it appeared that a lightning storm that moved through the city more than six hours earlier was to blame.

“Lightning,” he said, “struck the rear of the house on the third floor.”

The home, owned by Jonathan Martin of Stoneboro, Mercer County, is divided into three apartments — one on each floor. Three tenants live in each apartment.

Martha Fergus, 53, was in the living room in her third-floor apartment and in the direct line of the lightning strike about 8:30 p.m. Wednesday.

Neighbors reported hearing and seeing lightning hit the house.

“It blew a hole through the wall,” Ban said. “(Fergus) saw the plaster fly out.”

Fergus touched the wall, which was hot. Moments later, she saw flames.

The bolt of lightning also knocked out cable television and Internet service at the house. The electricity was not disrupted.

“(Fergus) threw water from the sink on (the fire),” Ban said. “She thought it was out.”

No one called to report what happened. Meanwhile, the fire was still smoldering in the wall.

The fire call eventually came in at 2:59 a.m., authorities said. Then police were making sure everyone in the home was out.

There were no working smoke detectors inside, officials said.

Safely evacuated were Fergus, 21-year-old daughter Kathleen Fergus and Kathleen's boyfriend, Brian Thomas, 26.

Evacuated from the second-floor were Stephen Kuzma, 44; his wife Robin Kuzma, 36; and their 18-month-old son, Joshua.

From the first floor, evacuated were Faith Naedele, 27, and her daughters, 5-year-old Charlotte Kinney and 3-year-old Winnie Kinney.

“When we got there we saw the whole roof in the back was on fire,” Ban said. “It was blazing.”

A fire crew took a hose up the top of the steps and within minutes had the fire extinguished.

Damage to the house is estimated at $30,000, with another $15,000 to $20,000 in damage to the contents of Fergus' apartment.

Minimal, if any, damage was reported to the other apartments.

Authorities do not know if Martin has homeowner's insurance. None of the tenant had renter's insurance

The Butler chapter of the American Red Cross was called to assist the tenants with emergency needs.

Fergus, her daughter and boyfriend are temporarily staying at a motel. The other tenants are staying with family members.

Ban said the circumstances of the fire should serve as a lesson to others.

“I hope anyone who experiences any natural stuff like lightning calls us,” he said, “just so we can check things out. We can detect problems that others can't see.”

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS