Cowher, Dungy 2 peas in a pod
Similarities run deep when it comes to Bill Cowher and Tony Dungy.
- Both were on the Kansas City Chiefs coaching staff from 1989-91, Cowher as defensive coordinator and Dungy as defensive backs coach.
- At 34, Cowher became the youngest head coach in the NFL when the Steelers hired him in 1992. At 25, Dungy became the youngest assistant coach in NFL history when the Steelers hired him in 1981.
- Cowher grew up in Crafton rooting for the Steelers and eventually coached them to a Super Bowl. Dungy played for the Steelers in a Super Bowl.
The two share something else in common that neither wants to continue: They are the two most successful coaches in the NFL who have never won a Super Bowl.
Cowher has guided the Steelers to the playoffs for the 10th time in 14 years. He is one of only six coaches in NFL history to win eight division titles.
Perhaps most impressively, Cowher is 100-1-1 during his career with the Steelers when his team has generated a lead of 10 points or more.
Dungy also has been a consistently successful head coach. In 10 years — four with Indianapolis, six with Tampa Bay — his teams have been to the playoffs eight times.
Between the two, Dungy and Cowher have guided their respective teams to seven conference championship games, but only one Super Bowl — and no Super Bowl titles.
That end result has been hurtful to both. Despite leading Tampa Bay to four playoff appearances in six years, the team fired Dungy because of playoff failures.
Since taking over the Colts, he has won 48 of 64 games, including a league-best 14-2 this year, and joined Ted Marchibroda as the only coach in franchise history to win 10-plus games and to reach the playoffs in each of his first three years with the team.
Cowher had to survive a power struggle with former director of football operations Tom Donahoe six years ago to keep his job. A 15-1 record last year, despite numerous injuries to starters on both sides of the ball all season, wasn't good enough for many Steelers fans who blamed him for the AFC title game loss to New England.
In this day and age, NFL coaches need to win a Super Bowl to validate their mark in the industry.
If Cowher or Dungy had won a Super Bowl by now, either would be considered a Hall of Fame caliber coach.
Because neither has succeeded on the league's biggest stage, neither figures to reach the Hall of Fame until he does.
Sunday's Steelers-Colts game represents another chance for both. While the winner moves on to yet another conference championship game, the loser will be talked about more.
If the Colts lose, a once potentially perfect season will have officially blown up in Dungy's face.
If the Steelers lose, it will be considered a typical Cowher season.
The proverbial monkey is on the back of both of these guys.
Consistency vs. championship?
Fans will take the latter every time.
John Enrietto is sports editor of the Butler Eagle
