OTHER VOICES
The energy bill the Senate overwhelmingly passed Tuesday is a lot weaker than it might have been but a lot stronger than the bill the House passed in April. The Senate's version would do more to make America secure by reducing our dependence on oil, and it takes a more responsible stance toward the environment.
The House and Senate negotiators who will try to resolve the massive differences between the bills are under tremendous pressure to succeed. From President Bush down, there's a strong sense that, given prices at the pump, Washington needs to do something.
That's true - unless it's the wrong something.
In this case, certain provisions of the House bill are the wrong something. Senators also should resist House attempts to undo the more progressive features of the Senate bill. If House negotiators won't budge, the Senate should simply say, "No deal."
Neither version will actually bring down energy prices in the short term, something even the politicians will admit, if pressed. So walking away with no bill - as happened in last year's energy conference committee - would be no real tragedy.
Now, the sticking points:
Subsidies for oil and gas producers: The House bill is full of them; most should go. As Bush has said, with oil above $50 a barrel, taxpayers don't need to pay companies to search for it.
Power from renewable sources: The Senate bill calls for 10 percent of the nation's electricity to come from renewable sources such as wind and biomass by 2020 and provides subsidies for producers. The House should keep its hands off.
Liability protection for the makers of the gasoline additive MTBE: The House bill includes one; it needs to go. MTBE leaks have contaminated groundwater across the country; manufacturers should not be automatically exempt when blame is assessed.
Carbon caps: A Senate resolution says mandatory controls on carbon emissions will be necessary to curb global warming, but it falls short of enacting such controls. Senators should rebuff any House assault on this symbolic victory for science.
