AL's rule over NL temporary
With the All-Star break arriving after play this weekend, the National League is feeling a bit inferior to its junior circuit counterpart.
When it comes to head-to-head play, the American League certainly has had the upper hand of late. Back-to-back World Series sweeps and eight consecutive All-Star Game victories have been followed by the ALposting a 154-98 edge in interleague play this season.
That's a whopping .611 winning percentage.
In the American League, you've got the Detroit Tigers, Chicago White Sox, Boston Red Sox, New York Yankees, Toronto Blue Jays and Minnesota Twins all playing pretty good baseball going into the break.
In the National League, you've got the New York Mets — and that's about it.
No doubt, the American League is where the action is this season.
The key words in that sentence are "this season."
Don't be so quick to crown the ALas the superior league in baseball now and forever more.
Folks tried doing that in football with the NFCyears back when the 49ers and Cowboys ruled the roost and the NFCwas winning every Super Bowl in sight. The AFChas certainly stated its case since.
Just like the NFCand AFCin football, the American and National leagues in baseball derive their players from the same sources. They participate in the same draft and have the same connections in the Dominican Republic and overseas.
And while the American League kicked the NL's collective rear this season — the Red Sox and Twins were 16-2 and the Tigers were 15-3 in interleague play — the history of play between the two leagues suggests no such domination.
Including this year, the ALhas won 1,249 interleague games since the leagues began playing each other in 1997. The NLhas won 1,202 games.
That gives the ALa 47-game edge over nine years. Before this season, the NLhad a nine-game edge over eight years.
In interleague play history, four American League clubs — Oakland, the Yankees, White Sox and Seattle — have interleague winning percentages above .530. So do four National League clubs — Florida, Atlanta, St. Louis and Houston.
Seven ALclubs have all-time interleague records below .500. So do seven NLclubs.
The only difference between the two leagues is in how the game is played. With the designated hitter rule, AL clubs emphasize hitting, which is reflected in the earned run averages of the league's pitching staffs.
NLclubs generally have deeper benches because they need them. NLteams tend to play "small ball" more often as well.
The American League is power personified. The National League is more strategic in nature.
Fans have their preferences, and that's fine. But as far as one league being better than the other year in and year out?
Sell that argument if you must, but I'm not buying it.
