Meet the endlessly supportive setter teeing up Freeport girls’ PIAA volleyball championship run
Freeport girls volleyball’s biggest personality is one of its smallest players.
Caylee Zembrzuski is an outgoing, commanding, uplifting and wildly effective fulcrum of the undefeated Yellowjackets (24-0) about to contend for their third PIAA championship, all packed into a 5-foot-6 frame.
Head coach Tom Phillips called the junior the best setter in the WPIAL regardless of classification before the season, and Zembrzuski has played like it throughout the postseason.
She has a knack for knowing when to feed the hot hand and when to get the ball to other weapons — and Freeport has a lot of them: from outside hitters Evie Tola, Emily Boylan and Brynleigh Paga (who also slides into the middle at times) to middle hitters Jayme Radvan and Lucy Majersky. She can shoot quick sets and slides and perfectly place a 3-ball to the outside, dump a shot over an unsuspecting block when she has to and also has one of the team’s best serves.
“She has that setter mentality,” Phillips said Wednesday after the ’Jackets first practice preparing for District 3 champion Trinity (21-2) in the PIAA Class 3A Girls Volleyball Championship game Saturday, Nov. 21, at St. Francis University’s Stokes Athletic Center.
By that he means the volleyball IQ to read defenses and manipulate them. And also the leadership skills to know when to go to which hitter while also being able to manage her teammates.
“Early on, I had to tell her, ‘When you’re out as a setter, your friends don’t matter,’” Phillips said.
Though friends Zembrzuski certainly has.
“She’s just so sweet and so supportive,” said Paga, a sophomore who has become a key rotational piece this postseason.
“She has a great sense of humor,” said Majersky, another of the vaunted sophomore class that had Phillips thinking state championship as early as two years ago. “She’s very relatable, too.”
Zembrzuski is kind of a late bloomer in the Freeport volleyball system.
She grew up playing four other sports — lacrosse, soccer, basketball and cheerleading — then discovered volleyball camps in sixth grade. She joined the middle school team the next year, where coaches decided to make her a setter, and made it her sole focus not long after.
She was named the starting varsity setter as a freshman and plays club ball for A-10 Volleyball Club. Zembrzuski is getting college interest from some Division II and III coaches, and she’s leaning toward Pittsburgh-area programs like Point Park, Chatham, Seton Hill and Penn State-Altoona, she said.
“I think most importantly is keeping the team uplifted, especially when we’re down,” said the self-described “pretty outgoing” Zembrzuski. “I think mental game is probably more important than physical game.”
WPIAL champion Freeport has not dropped a set since the district semifinals against Seton LaSalle and has dominated nearly every opponent this season. The Yellowjackets are the No. 2-ranked team in the state, per the Pennsylvania Volleyball Coaches Association, behind only their upcoming opponent.
A big reason why is Zembrzuski’s ability to manage the flow of the game and her teammates. While senior libero Macy Stivenson and Freeport’s back row have been excellent all postseason, it falls on Zembrzuski to dish to her various weapons from there.
“It’s not about keeping everyone happy, but it’s about knowing when’s the right time to give certain people the ball,” she said.
Combined with the team’s dangerous service game, Freeport is a well-rounded team that has been the “tough out” Phillips has wanted them to be all season.
They’re also a fun bunch. Zembrzuski carries a megawatt smile all match — it’s especially easy to do through 24 straight wins — and makes sure to provide positive encouragement to every teammate.
“The setter cheers the team on and is the team captain,” Majersky said.
Zembrzuski also knows how to crack the team’s legendary coach. She’s been a mastermind the past two years behind the team cosplaying as Phillips for their yearly “dress-up practice,” gold hat and all.
Maintaining that kind of energy and her consistency, which Paga highlighted as a strength, will be key against an equally talented and lengthy Shamrocks team also looking for its third state title.
“Everybody’s so connected,” Majersky said. “We’ve reached a flow state.”
Site/time: St. Francis University’s Stokes Athletic Center, 3:30 p.m.
Championship history: Freeport is 2-0 in PIAA title games, last winning in 2022 over District 3’s York Catholic 3-0. Trinity is 2-2, last winning in 2024 over District 10’s Corry.
Key players: It’s easy to name Freeport’s entire rotation, so let’s single out seniors Radvan and Stivenso, who will be the centerpieces of the Yellowjackets’ block and defense. Trinity brings a size advantage to this one and has a talented sophomore setter in Quinlan Bilodeau (6-foot-2). Senior outside hitter Sophie vander Velden had 15 kills and 12 digs in Saturday’s state quarterfinal. Junior middle/outside Brinley Howsare (6-2) is the team’s best player.
Key to the game for Freeport: The Yellowjackets know their recipe quite well and there’s no reason to change things up: play elite defense, get into system and let Zembrzuski feed her plethora of weapons. Freeport knows how to play undersized, so matching up against the Shamrocks’ length is nothing new. Phillips pointed out Radvan as the X-factor. With her size at middle, if she can affect Trinity’s attack, it could go a long way to deciding the champion.
