Site last updated: Thursday, November 19, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

English's overseas subsidies plan better than trade rights bill

Republican trade policy leaders are trying to rush the U.S. Trade Rights Enforcement Act (H.R. 3283) through the House of Representatives in a ploy to gain quick passage of the controversial Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA).

But the U.S. Trade Rights Enforcement Act is a ruse. House Republicans demanding stronger trade policy enforcement before supporting more trade liberalization like CAFTA will gain little or nothing from passage of H.R. 3283.

House members who support CAFTA in return for House passage of the U.S. Trade Rights Enforcement Act will have been duped or will have intentionally folded under pressure from the Republican leadership and the lobbyists for multinational companies and foreign governments.

Republican trade-policy leaders know it will take a long, uphill political battle to implement the U.S. Trade Rights Enforcement Act. If it passes the House, it will not be implemented until it passes the Senate, which will not happen soon, if ever.

It also would require the president’s signature, and that is unlikely.

But even if it were to be implemented, there is little beef in this enforcement legislation.

The U.S. Trade Rights Enforcement Act is a seriously flawed and weakened version of the Stopping Overseas Subsidies Act (H.R. 1216) introduced earlier this year by U.S. Rep. Phil English.

H.R. 1216, together with the China Currency Act of 2005 (H.R. 1498), would have provided an effective tool for injured manufacturers to neutralize the mercantilist practices of the Chinese and other foreign competitors.

On the other hand, CAFTA has already passed the Senate and it is one of the top legislative priorities of President George W. Bush. If it passes the House, it will go directly to the president, who will sign it into law immediately.

So, while the public and undecided members of Congress are being told that there is a direct trade-off of H.R. 3283 for CAFTA, in reality it’s a bait-and-switch scam to get the trade-liberalization train back on the fast track while the trade-law-enforcement train remains sidetracked — parked in the station and awaiting significant repair.

The illegal trade practices of many of our trading partners are destroying domestic manufacturing, stealing American jobs, and devastating American communities and the U.S. economy.

Elected representatives who are truly listening to the broad grass-roots outcry against the profound negative effects of reckless trade liberalization must hold the line and not fall for this ploy to pass CAFTA without real action to effectively address the host of U.S.-China trade problems, such as currency manipulation, massive export subsidies, and the soaring trade deficit.

Dave Frengel is director of government affairs for Penn United Technology, Inc.; executive director of Manufacturers for Fair Trade; and chairman of the Government Affairs Committee of the Pittsburgh Chapter, National Tooling and Machining Association.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS