Site last updated: Thursday, November 19, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

OTHER VOICES

Hybrid vehicles - those gas-electric fuel misers - are moving beyond Hollywood status symbols into the mainstream. More automakers are making them, and more consumers are interested, especially as gasoline hovers over $2 a gallon.

The first hybrids - the Honda Insight and Toyota Prius - devoted their technology to cutting fuel consumption and reducing air pollution. They made owners feel virtuous, but they were small, expensive and not very fast.

As hybrids move into their next generation, automakers want models with wider appeal - larger vehicles with more amenities that can carry families and all their belongings.

But they're making too many compromises that are taking the "green" out of this purchase.

In the last 20 years, automotive engineers have significantly advanced the design of conventional engines, transmissions and power trains. They could have applied this new technology to improving fuel efficiency and saved billions of barrels of imported oil. They didn't. Instead, they increased vehicle weight, horsepower and acceleration.

The results: stagnant fuel economy and rising oil imports.

Now manufacturers are applying the same technological tricks to hybrids. Newer models, including the Lexus RX 400h, trade much of their fuel conservation for performance. Critics have dubbed them "muscle hybrids."

Muscle cars and Birkenstocks don't mix.

The 2005 Honda Accord Hybrid, for example, uses the same V-6 engine as the conventional model, then takes extra zip from its electric motor to boost the car's 0-60 m.p.h. acceleration. With its Civic Hybrid, by contrast, Honda reduced the size of the gas engine before adding the electric motor, thereby breaking even on horsepower, and saving fuel. In May, Consumer Reports rated the 2005 Accord Hybrid and base models as having about the same gas mileage. It's a waste of innovative technology that could help save oil.

Fortunately, Congress recognized this disturbing trend when authorizing new consumer tax breaks in the energy bill that just passed. Previously, buyers qualified for a tax deduction for any hybrid. Beginning in 2006, consumers can get a credit of $250 to $3,400, depending on the fuel efficiency of the vehicle. The more gas it saves, the higher the credit.

But Congress limited the numbers of vehicles eligible for the credit to 60,000 per manufacturer. That penalizes companies that now have the best products on the market and rewards Detroit's laggards. Toyota will likely reach its limit within the first six months of 2006.

Cost was arguably a factor in the cap, but the alternative vehicle tax credit amounted to less than $1 billion in a $14.5 billion bill packed with subsidies for oil and other companies that make huge profits. Consumers got too little.

Consumers are right to look into hybrid technology. But they shouldn't fall for hybrid hype.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS