Site last updated: Thursday, November 19, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

State courts have a role in pay-hike fiasco

Why did the General Assembly enact the pay raise in the way it did? Because the Supreme Court has told them it's OK.

In a series of rulings over many years, the court has made clear that our Constitution's requirements for bills to address a single subject, to maintain their original purpose, and especially to be considered on three different days in each chamber simply don't mean what they say. The result is that citizens have no protection, from any of the three branches of government, against stealth legislation.

For example, the court upheld the gambling law even though not one word of the original bill was included in the final law, and the final law was considered for only a matter of hours. The court ruled that the final law addressed the same subject "in reasonably broad terms" as the original bill, and therefore citizens were on notice of what might happen.

This is exactly what happened with the pay raise law just weeks after the court ruling. Not one original word survived, and the final law was considered for even less time than the gambling law. But the final product addressed the same subject "in reasonably broad terms" as the original.

Every subject you can think of is already under consideration "in reasonably broad terms" in the House and Senate. As of August 10, there were 1,926 bills introduced in the House and 844 bills introduced in the Senate since January. Legislative leaders therefore can pass the Supreme Court's test by positioning an appropriate bill (they call it a "vehicle"), gutting it, inserting any language they want, as long as the end result addresses the same subject "in reasonably broad terms."

Two Pennsylvania Supreme Court justices who have contributed to this series of rulings are up for retention election this year - Justice Sandra Shultz Newman and Justice Russell Nigro. Pennsylvanians deserve to hear their answers to a few questions before the November election.

Versions of the following questions are appropriate for the judges on all state and local courts, but especially for those seeking retention on the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.Will Justices Newman and Nigro accept the pay raise?Chief Justice Ralph Cappy has revealed (in his July op-ed) that the pay raise was being negotiated over a year's time. Did Justices Newman and Nigro know that Chief Justice Cappy was seeking this pay raise?Was it appropriate for Chief Justice Cappy to be working with the legislature and the governor for a year to create this pay raise plan without the knowledge and participation of the public?What would it take to violate the three-day rule if any final bill addresses the same subject "in reasonably broad terms" as the original bill?To whom does the court owe greater deference – the legislature or the people? Who is the sovereign under the Constitution – the legislature or the people? Who elects Supreme Court justices – the legislature or the people?Would other interpretations of the legislature's compliance with the Constitution's "three-day rule" be appropriate, or do you believe that the Supreme Court's rulings are absolutely correct and that there is no room for the rulings to be reversed by a subsequent court?Can the court recognize that there is more than one way to enact legislation, including the way that the Constitution's plain language lays out? Shouldn't the court give preference to that manner of enactment and give less legitimacy to actual procedures according to how far they stray from the Constitution's requirements?Is it appropriate for citizens who are upset at stealth legislation to vote against the retention of justices such as Newman and Nigro who have interpreted the Constitution to permit stealth legislation?

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS