Other Voices
Kofi Annan says he's not hiding anything, but a controversial e-mail has investigators wisely taking another look at the U.N. secretary-general's possible involvement in the oil-for-food scandal.
Annan and his son Kojo have long denied rumors linking them to corruption in a program that allowed Saddam Hussein's dictatorship to sell oil and misuse cash earmarked for humanitarian aid. In a report earlier this year, independent investigators led by former Federal Reserve chief Paul Volcker said they had no conclusive evidence that Annan knew that Cotecna, his son's employer, was a bidder on a program contract or whether the younger Annan influenced the contract.
But a follow-up report released Monday raises new questions. In addition to accusing top former U.N. executives Benon Sevan and Alexander Yakovlev of corruption, this investigation disclosed an e-mail that suggests a Cotecna vice president and friend of the Annans had "brief discussions" with the secretary-general in late November 1998 about the status of Cotecna's negotiations. The executive, Michael Wilson, has denied authorship, but investigators say the e-mail appears to be authentic.
Annan and his son haven't spoken directly on this matter. In an attempt to deflect criticism, a spokesman for Annan said Monday that top executives aren't always aware of corruption and conflicts of interest in the middle levels of their organization. He also said the secretary-general remains committed to reforming the U.N.
As investigators concede, this probe needs to go deeper than Sevan, the program's former administrator, who is accused of receiving illegal kickbacks, and Yakovlev, a former U.N. procurement officer who pleaded guilty Monday to bribery, wire fraud and money-laundering charges.
The United Nations has massive credibility and management issues, problems made worse by the suspicions that dog Annan and growing evidence of Saddam Hussein's wholesale manipulation of the U.N.
The inquiry panel's next report, which investigators say will focus on Annan's activities, must outline his role in unfettered detail. Unless it does, serious overdue reform of U.N. leadership, conduct and policies is a pipe dream.
