Site last updated: Thursday, November 19, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Commissioners impose time limits

The Butler County commissioners will have less time to speak their piece.

The commissioners on Wednesday adopted two procedural changes to public meetings, limiting the time they can give reports and the length of their responses to residents’ comments.

Beginning at the May 8 meeting, the commissioners will be restricted to 10-minute reports and two-minute responses to public comments.

Through Wednesday, there were no time limits for the commissioners.

Commissioner Jim Eckstein opposed both changes, saying they were attempts to prevent him from exposing information to the public.

Eckstein said the county should seek comments from its residents before altering how meetings are conducted.

“You’re not getting public input,” he said.

Commissioner Bill McCarrier, board chairman, said the moves were done to shorten meetings.

“It’s not for us to conduct an election campaign,” he said about commissioner reports.

Eckstein accused McCarrier and Commissioner Dale Pinkerton of wanting to prevent certain issues from being discussed publicly.

While Eckstein said 10 minutes would be sufficient most of the time, his report may need to be longer when major issues are on the table.

McCarrier reminded him the commissioners have no time limits on how long they discuss motions up for a vote.

“We can talk as long as we want about it,” he said.

Eckstein vowed to ignore the 10-minute restriction on reports when such decisions as the future of the Sunnyview Nursing and Rehabilitation Center are being considered.

“When they sell Sunnyview, I’m going to run over my 10 minutes,” Eckstein said.

He accused Pinkerton of stating repeatedly the county should explore selling its nursing home, which loses money. Pinkerton denied making any such comment.

McCarrier also disputed Eckstein’s accusation, but conceded the county may explore the possibility of selling the nursing home someday.

“It’s always an option,” McCarrier said.

When Eckstein said the other two commissioners don’t let him add items to meeting agendas, Pinkerton challenged him to name one instance when that occurred. Eckstein said he would compile a list.

McCarrier said the new two-minute response limit should encourage residents to speak before the board.

He said people are intimidated from speaking during public comment because they see how Eckstein treats others.

Eckstein disagreed there were people afraid to speak because of him. He demanded McCarrier disclose who made those comments, then claimed they don’t exist.

“There are no people,” Eckstein said.

He said there should be time for him to respond to residents’ questions.

“You’re going to violate my free speech rights,” he said.

McCarrier disagreed, saying meetings are meant for county business.

“It’s not a time for dialogue between the commissioners and the public,” he said.

McCarrier stressed residents will have the same three minutes to speak while having the opportunity to talk with the commissioners at other times.

“They can call me anytime,” he said.

County solicitor Mike English confirmed the commissioners have the right to set time limits on themselves without seeking public input beforehand.

Pinkerton said the time limits should improve meetings.

“Hopefully, these minor changes will have a positive outcome,” he said.

Eckstein insisted it’s his constitutional right to be allowed to speak longer.

He compared himself to Rosa Parks, a black civil rights activist who made history by refusing to move to the back of a bus.

Eckstein on Monday said the American Civil Liberties Union told him his comments couldn’t be limited.

Sara Rose, staff attorney for the ACLU, said in an interview she couldn’t comment on a specific conversation between the organization and an individual.

However, Rose did speak in general terms. She said county commissioners aren’t prohibited from setting time limits on themselves as long as it’s applied equally.

“It would be unconstitutional if the other commissioners limit one particular commissioner’s speech,” she said.

Despite being told about Rose’s comments, Eckstein said in an interview he would oppose the enforcement of the new limits.

“They’re trying to muzzle me,” he said. “How do they stop me from doing it?”

At the April 10 meeting, McCarrier and Pinkerton stopped Eckstein from continuing to talk by adjourning the meeting.

During the meeting Wednesday, Eckstein told McCarrier that was the only way to prevent him from talking.

“You’ll have to keep adjourning the meeting,” Eckstein said.

“We can do that,” McCarrier said.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS