Amanda Smail-Carrizalez, wife of former Butler resident who self-deported to Mexico, dies
The highly-covered journey of a Butler family that self-deported after a husband and father’s detainment by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement appears to have unexpectedly taken a tragic turn.
Amanda Smail-Carrizalez, the wife of former Butler resident and Mexico native Ignacio Carrizalez and mother of 7-year-old Dani Carrizalez, has died, according to the Tamaulipas Attorney General’s office. Tamaulipas is the Mexican state the Carrizalezes moved to from Butler.
A representative at the office said a woman with the same name was found near the Carrizalezes’ town of residence, Estacion Manuel.
The cause of the death is currently not known, but the Butler Eagle has reached out to Smail-Carrizalez’s family for more information.
Ignacio Carrizalez had previously spent years in the United States undocumented. In recent years, he had documentation as he and Amanda tried to navigate the U.S. immigration system. But he was reportedly detained by masked U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents without a warrant in Evans City and was held for over two months at Moshannon Valley Processing Center, a Clearfield County facility that’s garnered attention for alleged poor conditions and treatment of detainees.
He was released in July, weeks after an immigration judge gave him the option to self-deport from America.
The shocking news comes roughly a month after the family departed Butler and drove thousands of miles to Ignacio Carrizalez’s hometown in southern Tamaulipas.
Several people who knew Smail-Carrizalez made social media posts Tuesday, confirming she had been found deceased.
One family member said Smail-Carrizalez was a beautiful soul who will be loved and missed.
In the weeks leading up to her death, Smail-Carrizalez made a number of social media posts expressing frustration at the Trump Administration, her husband and a general malaise toward adjusting to life in Mexico.
Jaime Martinez, executive director of Frontline Dignity, said the organization is “deeply heartbroken” to learn about Smail-Carrizalez’s death. He asked for people to honor her life by remembering her humanity and “the inherent dignity that belongs to every person.
“In moments of profound suffering, we’re reminded of our shared responsibility to meet one another not with judgment but with tenderness and compassion,” he said. “We must also recognize the immense emotional and psychological burdens that the ongoing immigration crisis places on families and entire communities.
“These are burdens that too often remain unseen, and they deserve our attention and our empathy.”
Butler County Sheriff Mike Slupe said he will be sending thoughts and prayers to Smail-Carrizalez’s family, especially to her daughter.
