Site last updated: Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

North Catholic boys soccer falls short of first PIAA championship berth after loss to Fairview

View and purchase Eagle photos at photos.butlereagle.com

FRANKLIN — Scott Schlegel saw the type of game he was hoping for out of his North Catholic boys soccer team.

The only thing he would change is the final score.

Fairview forward Joseph Chiocco scored on a penalty kick in the 26th minute, the only goal in a 1-0 victory against the Trojans in Tuesday’s PIAA Class 2A semifinal at Franklin High School.

Related Article: See the 2026 PIAA Boys Soccer Championships brackets | Seneca Valley and North Catholic’s semifinal sites, times Related Article: North Catholic beats Belle Vernon in shootout in PIAA boys soccer quarterfinals to make final four

“It was beautiful to watch two teams come out and want to possess the ball, play with grit but also play the right way,” Schlegel said. “They (Tigers) may have had two or three more scoring chances than us, but man, we had some good ones.”

Chiocco’s goal ended up in the left side of the net despite North goalie Logan Mueser guessing correctly when he dove to his right and even got a hand on the ball.

In a state quarterfinal win over WPIAL champ Belle Vernon on Saturday, Mueser came up with two clutch saves once the game moved to penalty kicks.

North Catholic' players react to loosing to Fairfield 1-0 in a PIAA Class 2A boys soccer semifinal game Tuesday, Nov. 17, 2026, at Franklin High School. Andrew Jackson/Butler Eagle

“Logan was a first-year goalie for us and played very well,” Schlegel said. “He allowed us to play more freely out of the back.”

For the second straight year, Fairview (23-0) will face District 4 champion and defending state champ Lewisburg, a 3-2 winner over District 12 champion Devon Prep on penalty kicks, in the PIAA final at 4 p.m. Saturday at Pittsburgh’s F.N.B. Stadium.

North also missed out on playing there when it lost in the WPIAL semifinals earlier this month.

Related Article: No. 3 North Catholic boys soccer thumps Burrell to once again return to WPIAL quarterfinals Related Article: Led by backup QB, North Catholic’s comeback falls short vs Hopewell in WPIAL football quarterfinals

“This is the second time this season that we ended up one game short of playing there,” Schlegel said. “It’s such a great venue, and I wanted our kids to play in front of a Pittsburgh crowd. I hate it that they won’t get that opportunity.”

The Trojans (20-3-2) were knocked out of the WPIAL playoffs last year in the quarterfinals. They responded this season by reaching the semifinals of both the district and state tournaments.

“We had a quality team last year but played with more grit this season,” North senior midfielder Jackson Schlegel said. “We won some scrappy, close games this year that we wouldn’t have won a year ago.”

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS