Assessment system ruled 'unjust'
PITTSBURGH — A state law allowing counties to use a base year system to assess property values is unconstitutional and produces "arbitrary, unjust, and unreasonably discriminatory results," a county judge ruled Wednesday.
Allegheny County Executive Dan Onorato said the county would appeal Judge R. Stanton Wettick Jr.'s order to the state Supreme Court — which Wettick anticipated in his ruling. The judge also suggested the Legislature may want to step in because other counties use the system.
"He basically put in play for the Supreme Court and the Legislature to do something," Onorato said.
In October 2005, Onorato and county council decided to set 2002 as the base year for assessments because they said using 2006 property values could mean large tax increases for about 9,000 people who bought property since 2002.
Three weeks later, opponents sued, saying the new system amounted to an illegal assessment freeze. Using 2002 values penalized property owners with decreasing or stagnant assessment values in poorer areas of the county, but gave tax breaks to property owners with increasing values in nicer areas, they said.
Attorneys for the plaintiffs welcomed the ruling.
"We think it's an essential step in correcting a great deal of non-uniformity that been allowed to exist in Pennsylvania for the last 25 years and particularly in Allegheny County since 2005," said attorney Donald F. Driscoll, who represented two residents from poorer communities. Wettick found their properties overassessed.
Ira Weiss, who represented other property owners, said "by all objective measuring points, this is an unfair system."
Wettick said the base year method violates the state constitution's uniformity clause, which requires taxes to be levied in an across-the-board fashion.
"First, this method of assessing real estate is invalid on its face because it inevitably produces arbitrary, unjust, and unreasonably discriminatory results," Wettick ruled.
"Second, this legislation has, in fact, in most counties produced substantial levels of inequality in the ratio of assessed values to market values that could be significantly reduced through periodic reassessments," he said.
