Site last updated: Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Repealing lawmakers'pay raise not enough

In the early hours of July 7, the Pennsylvania General Assembly passed the controversial pay-raise bill without public notice or input and knowing it would be wildly unpopular. The way this bill was enacted surprised many people, but it shouldn’t have because most bills of any importance or controversy are now passed this way in Harrisburg.

The pay-raise vote illustrates a larger problem. The manner in which legislative leadership moves major legislation has largely cut the public and rank-and-file legislators who represent them out of the law-making process.

Legislative leaders in Harrisburg who control the flow of legislation believe they are free to pass the bills they want in the way they want, despite public opinion or the requirements of the Pennsylvania Constitution, which sets out how bills must be passed.

Why do these leaders feel such immunity from public opinion and constitutional strictures? I believe there are at least three reasons:

n The high unlikelihood that legislative leaders or rank-and-file members will be defeated makes them feel immune from public pressure or backlash.

n Leadership has been given carte blanche over the legislative process by rank-and-file members.

n State courts have failed to require the legislature to pass laws in accordance with the procedures set out in the state constitution.

Incumbents have a tremendous advantage in Pennsylvania legislative elections. The General Assembly has an annual budget of $340 million, and legislative leaders who control these funds use a portion to protect themselves and other incumbents from being defeated.

Incumbent-protection tools such as public service announcements, telephone and e-mail campaigns, newsletters, radio and TV shows and more maximize name recognition and publicity for incumbents. In addition, the legislature in Pennsylvania controls the redistricting process, which leaders use to draw the safest election districts possible for incumbents.

It’s not surprising that the re-election rate for incumbents in the Pennsylvania legislature is about 98 percent.

Legislative leaders, such as the majority leader in the House and the president pro tempore of the Senate, control the flow of legislation — that is to say, what bills get voted on and when. These leaders serve at the pleasure of their rank-and-file members who, in theory, should act as a check against leadership’s misuse of authority.

Unfortunately, many rank-and-file members have ceded this power to the leaders in exchange for things like access to the incumbency-protection tools outlined above, as well as extra staff, community grants and movement of their pet legislation. This leads to a legislature where leadership feels free to move unpopular bills in an unconstitutional manner — like the pay raise.

Finally, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and Commonwealth Court have repeatedly failed to require the legislature to pass bills in accordance with the constitution. For example, Article III, Section 4, of the Pennsylvania Constitution requires legislation to be considered in both the House and Senate on three separate days before it is passed. The purpose of this requirement is to give rank-and-file legislators time to fully understand what they are voting on — and allow the public opportunity to comment.

Yet, legislative leaders routinely hold votes on important and controversial bills like the pay raise just hours after they are presented to rank-and-file members, with the public finding out the details only after the vote is taken.

In previous challenges, most recently to the gambling law (Act 71 of 2004), Commonwealth Court and the state Supreme Court failed to uphold this constitutional provision. Other constitutional provisions routinely ignored include requirements that bills not be amended to change their original purpose, that bills contain no more than one subject and that bills first be considered by a committee. Until our state courts force the legislature to pass bills in accord with the Pennsylvania Constitution, it won’t.

What can be done to change things?

First, Pennsylvania citizens need to look past the local grants their legislators secure and the constituent service they provide and evaluate whether their state representative or senator is strong enough to stand up to legislative leaders and be an independent voice for them in Harrisburg. The legislature does not need more “go-along guys.”

Second, the citizens of Pennsylvania should insist that candidates for the Pennsylvania Supreme Court and Commonwealth Court publicly state their position on requiring the General Assembly to follow the state constitution in passing legislation. Citizens should support judicial candidates who pledge to be legislative watchdogs.

Two Supreme Court judges are up for retention this November. Three Commonwealth Court positions are expected to be on the ballot in 2007.

And, third, constituents of the powerful legislative leaders must realize they have a special responsibility to hold their representatives and senators accountable when they pass legislation against the wishes of the public or in violation of the constitution. These citizens must let their representatives know they are paying attention and that there will be a political price to pay when leaders misuse their authority.

Pennsylvania citizens have been effectively cut out of the legislative process in Harrisburg, and it has been happening for a long time.

Citizens should not be satisfied with just overturning the pay-raise vote. Citizens need to do much more. They need to reassert their role in a state government that is supposed to be responsive to them, not independent of them.

They must fight to retain their voice in the legislative process.

Democratic State Rep. Greg Vitali represents the 166th District, located in Delaware County.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS