OTHER VOICES
The revised nomination of Judge John Roberts to the Supreme Court, this time as chief justice, strengthens the case for a thoughtful, deliberative but rigorous confirmation process. In the seven weeks since President Bush nominated Judge Roberts, initially to replace Sandra Day O'Connor, the picture that has emerged is generally positive. He is an affable, erudite and exceptionally able lawyer with broad experience in constitutional law. He is a conservative, but no extremist.
Judge Roberts, who earned a well-qualified rating from the American Bar Association, appears to have the makings of a strong Supreme Court justice. In a way, he was a safe choice as a replacement for Chief Justice William Rehnquist because liberal activists who wanted to thwart the nomination have found little in Judge Roberts' record to suggest that they would have any success. At the same time, elevating the nomination places an even deeper burdern on Congress to ask tough questions.
These hearings will give the American public the best -- and only -- opportunity to ponder his views on all those issues that roil the social and political landscape and eventually must be decided by the nation's highest court. The only true "litmus test" will be Judge Roberts' willingness to supply clear and honest answers to legitimate questions about his judicial philosophy and his opinions on issues ranging from abortion to federalism to privacy.
Most of what we know about Judge Roberts comes from thousands of pages of letters and memoranda that he wrote as a young lawyer in the Reagan White House. As a whole, this material shows that his views were very much in harmony with the president that he served. But much of this was written more than 20 years ago, just a few years after Roberts earned his degree from Harvard Law School.
The material is revealing, although there is no smoking gun that would disqualify him for a role on the Supreme Court. Among other things, he questioned the right to abortion - in fact, the entire notion of a right to privacy - and was skeptical of the idea that there is "a fundamental right to be free from discrimination." There are many other areas that could spell trouble, such as his views on federalism and individual rights. These are legitimate areas of inquiry. Senators must ask the questions, and he has a responsibility to reply. The Bush administration could help to fill in the sketchy picture by releasing memos that he wrote when he served in the Department of Justice in the administration of George H.W. Bush.
Inevitably, there will be some sparring with Democrats on the committee, who find themselves in a politically tricky position. The Democrats risk appearing overly partisan and too eager to disparage a respectable nominee. It will be difficult for Democrats to portray him as an extremist in view of the fact that only three members of their party cast votes against him in his 2003 confirmation hearing for an appellate position.
But considering that this is a lifetime appointment of a candidate with a short record on the bench, it's fair to ask probing questions to determine if Judge Roberts possesses the temperament and suitability to lead the Supreme Court. He must not be made to appear as something he is not, but neither should he get a free pass.
