Analysts play alphabet soup
Wall Street, meet Sesame Street.
Bulls, bears and Nobel laureates are talking a lot about letters as they try to predict the shape of the charts that will describe the economy's downturn and recovery.
Will this roller coaster follow the path of a "U" — a stretched-out slump with a sharp upturn? Or will it be shaped like a "V," with a vertiginous descent followed by a quick recovery? Will we wrestle with a "W"-shaped double dip, or labor through an "L" of long-term languishing?
Global Insight's May presentation "U.S. Recession and Recovery: U-, V-, or W-shaped?" answered with a "W," saying a second dip would come as spending from stimulus checks ends.
"There's been debate about whether it's V-shaped or U-shaped," Nobel-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz said recently on CNBC. "I think there's growing consensus it's an L-shape."
By focusing on letters, Wall Street is "trying to make a desperate situation look sort of technical — 'It's not that much of a fuss, the big boys can take care of it, don't you worry,"' said Wall Street historian Charles Geisst. "Except the big boys here, their trousers are getting a little short, I'm afraid."
So far, the downward ride has included record bank writedowns and home foreclosures, the wipeout of $1.9 trillion in shareholder wealth and a spike in unemployment.
The alphabet-shaped charts represent the rise and fall of economic indicators over time — such as Gross Domestic Product, real income, employment, industrial production and wholesale sales. The National Bureau of Economic Research, the chart-watching private group that gauges economic peaks and troughs, has yet to declare the current downturn a recession. Plenty of others have, saying the charts are proving their point to the letter.
"This could extend itself well into 2009, with repercussions that could keep the country stagnant for two or three years," said Jay Brew, chief bank strategist at community bank strategy firm M. Rae Resources Inc. and an "L" proponent.
Past recessions did, in retrospect, follow certain scripts. The 1980 recession proved to be a quick "V," as measured in changes in GDP. The next recession, in 1981 and '82, looked more "W"-like. The 1990-91 recession showed "U"-like traits, while the 2001 recession was another "W."
The obsession with shapes is a departure for Wall Street, where metaphors tend to be about hunting, war or sex. Partners at Wall Street firms who bring in good deals are said to "eat what they kill" come bonus time. When one company reveals its finances to another, it "opens the kimono" so the two sides can conduct an "open kimono transaction."
Some players are sticking with macho themes, spurning the alphabet and running with sports metaphors.
"We're not expecting this to be a hockey stick in the true sense of a hockey stick of a year at all," said Dominic Romeo, chief financial officer at pump products maker Idex, according to a transcript of the company's fourth-quarter earnings call in February.
