As China flexes its muscles, it’s time to take a deep breath
With China National Offshore Oil Corp.’s unsolicited bid for Unocal, a U.S. oil company, Americans are receiving a taste of what Beijing’s economic ascent means.
No question, it is unsettling when a player on any scene acquires new power and begins to assume roles that some people had not considered. China’s lingering Communist influence further complicates the discussion, fueling suspicion and fear.
To many, Beijing’s increasingly prominent swagger in economic circles signals danger and warrants — even to otherwise sensible and free-market-oriented minds — a rush to the U.S. government for protection.
Instead, I would recommend taking a deep breath. As the discussion develops over the CNOOC bid — which could easily falter on multiple bureaucratic and political hurdles — Americans should rely less on emotion and more on realities.
In any event, the CNOOC proposal, which follows in the footsteps of other Chinese companies’ attempts to snatch up prominent businesses, should come as no surprise. They clearly aim to use those acquisitions to boost their presence in international markets and achieve the kind of brand-name attention that ordinarily would take years. Nor, necessarily, do the attempted purchases portend danger.
For the longest time, China was a paper giant: large, heavily populated and displaying a grand tradition, but mired in turbulent politics and suffering from an economic backwater status. Then came Deng Xiaoping, who in the late 1970s spurred the reforms that shaped the steel-and-concrete Chinese behemoth that now prowls the global economy and feeds an insatiable appetite for natural resources.
Many Americans have welcomed China’s reforms. Despite a hefty trade deficit in China’s favor that emerged fairly early, U.S. firms and consumers have enjoyed numerous benefits. Moreover, constructive engagement could eventually transform Beijing into a free, friendly and integrated member of the global community. To date, political change has not paced economic reform, but some progress is undeniable — especially at the village level.
Others have looked at China more critically, grumbling in particular about Beijing’s unique approach to capitalism, which involves a heavy state hand. That leaves China’s economy partly free, partly interlaced with private and state fingers and partly the exclusive domain of the government. The fact that CNOOC is state-controlled thus raises warning flags.
Still others — the habitual China-bashers — have viewed Beijing as purely opportunistic and dangerous. They have always contended that it was just a matter of time before China would perceive diminishing benefits from working with the United States and turn on this country.
Furthermore, they have never accepted that anything good could derive from a system so fraught with contradictions. After all, how could a government simultaneously practice a Communist philosophy and a free-market one? Is it not obvious, they ask, that the Chinese Communists wish to strengthen their country, at the West’s expense, and hold on to their positions? At some point, as power builds, ambitions soar and military strength increases, will China not challenge and even find itself in conflict with the United States?
Well, I have never been one to side with extreme perspectives — and the overly negative attitudes toward China plainly fall into that category. Their proponents fail to take into consideration that the Chinese are undergoing changes too potent, rapid and widespread for even the most attentive Communist managers to control. In addition, China’s political leaders are fighting a losing battle for legitimacy.
I reject the results that pessimists project for China — that it could succumb to one of history’s most dramatic meltdowns by the end of this decade or that the Communists could reimpose their grip and confront the United States.
Instead, I see the evolution of China into a big Taiwan, which would make Beijing companies’ attempted acquisition of American firms in the future no more of a problem than would be the case if, for example, Europeans were doing the bidding.
In the meantime, whether Americans view the Chinese as friendly or not, they should brace themselves for a flurry of acquisitions as China muscles its way into the multinational club.
John C. Bersia, a Pulitzer Prize-winning editorial writer for the Orlando Sentinel, is also the special assistant to the president for global perspectives and a professor at the University of Central Florida.
