Annual optimism for Bucs wears thin
For three days earlier this month, the city of Pittsburgh was the center of the baseball world.
Now, with the Major League All-Star Game over, the Pirates and their fans must go back to their place in the hierarchy of baseball: sitting next to the dinner table waiting to catch a few scraps as the better teams gear up for the playoff chase — or at least a chase for a winning record.
Some feel bad for the Pirates, but they've earned their dubious status in baseball by compiling a 37-66 record to this point that is the worst record in the National League and, if it weren't for the Kansas City Royals, it would be the worst record in all of baseball.
There will always be fans who, no matter how bad the situation is, can always see the light at the end of the tunnel.
I recently overheard a Pittsburgh sportscaster say that the reason there is hope is because this is the first time since the Pirates last made the playoffs in 1992 that the team has a crop of good young players, from position players to pitchers, who will carry Pittsburgh back to respectability and a winning record.
I just shook my head.
I've got a pretty good memory, and I can tell you that every year since 1992, I can recall fans and Pittsburgh sportscasters giving reasons to be optimistic about the Pirates.
The reason people are looking back on those seasons (1993-present) and saying there was no hope for the Pirates is because the team, surprise, surprise, did not fulfill expectations.
But hindsight is 20/20. You have to look at what expectations the team had going into a season, not five or six years after the fact.
I'll use the 2000 season as an example. Heading into that year, the Pirates had a young pitcher named Kris Benson who had won 11 games as a rookie in 1999, a season in which the Pirates went 78-83.
Todd Ritchie and Jason Schmidt had combined for 28 wins in 1999. That's three pitchers and 39 victories the season before and you know Pirates fans were optimistic about that.
There was a left-fielder named Brian Giles, who, in his first season in a Pittsburgh uniform, belted 39 home runs and drove in 115 runs while batting .315 in 1999. Those numbers reek of optimism.
The team's young second baseman was Warren Morris, the same player who finished second in the NL Rookie of the Year race in 1999. Heck, no — that's no reason to be optimistic.
And how about that young, power-hitting third baseman named Aramis Ramirez?
And, of course, 2000 was the final season at Three Rivers Stadium. The Pirates had visions of moving into PNC Park in 2001 and, abracadabra, a winning record would follow.
Unfortunately, ballparks don't win ballgames.
The bottom line is, every year there's reason to be optimistic. And by the end of every season it's, "We'll be contenders in a few years." Then, in a few years, it's the same story all over again. The Pirates are running on a treadmill.
Over the last 14 seasons, the Pirates have been like the boy who cried wolf. In this case, the wolf is a winning record, and I'm not holding my breath for it.
