As Butler football gets ready for ‘Butler County Super Bowl’ with Karns City, team still facing skepticism
Friday night’s matchup between Butler and Karns City football is the first of its kind.
The teams are already giving it some lofty names.
“We’ve titled this the Butler County 2026 Super Bowl,” Golden Tornado head coach Eric Christy said.
“Our coaches put it as the Ohio State-Michigan (game),” Butler senior Nicco Baggetta said. “We’re Michigan walking into ‘The Shoe,’ and we’re coming out on top, baby.”
Baggetta is looking forward to seeing — and quieting — the wave of purple at Karns City’s Diehl Stadium, there to cheer on the local District 9 Class 2A power.
“They fill the stands every week, no matter who they play,” said Baggetta, who tore the UCL in his throwing elbow and is playing through it with a brace on his arm and has switched from quarterback to running back. “No matter what the score is, everyone is (like), ‘Good game.’ No matter what happens, it’s always a positive attitude from the community and from the players and from everyone.
“For us, we might not have that community as much, but we have each other.”
Butler’s departure from the WPIAL to join District 10 and eventually go independent in recent years has been well-documented. Christy and the program hope to one day rejoin the WPIAL.
But regardless of recent success — a 4-3 record so far this season, 7-3 last year — the Tornado still face criticism at times from within their own community. There are social media comments after wins that mock the team for playing small schools.
“For the most part, you feel for the kids in the situation,” Christy said. “I think people forget the fact that they are just high school kids. They’re not NFL players who are making a living out of this. … I think sometimes people just lose sight of the fact of what they’re badmouthing. It’s your hometown, it’s your community, it’s the kids who are your neighbors.
“It would be nice if you rallied around them and you got behind this group.”
There is support in Butler — other fans, administrators, parents and coaches, and the players “have good connections on the field and off the field, and … we all bring each other up,” Baggetta said.
Christy called the locker room environment “a breath of fresh air.” Student-athletes show up for practice every day to play 10 games.
Players and coaches are realistic about the state the program is in. The Tornado have made strides and are on the brink of consecutive winning seasons, a big step since consecutive 0-10 runs in 2018 and 2019.
Butler cannot rejoin the WPIAL until 2028 at the earliest, at the start of the next PIAA two-year scheduling cycle, but Christy and Butler leadership have stated in the past the program must have sustained success with high win totals to feel ready for WPIAL Class 6A play.
“We’re not a North Allegheny … and everyone knows that,” Baggetta said. “And we’re trying to get to that point, of course. But no matter what we do, it’s going to be a lose-lose situation. (If) we go back to the WPIAL and play the 6A gauntlet — as we’ve referred to it — and just get annihilated every game, the community’s gonna hate it.”
“I don’t think anyone’s disillusioned on anything,” Christy said. “No one’s going, ‘Hey, we’re gonna go beat Central Catholic next week.’ … But (our current schedule is) a good brand of football. People wanna come out here on Friday nights and see close games where it’s a battle and either team can win.”
That could be the case Friday against Karns City (6-1), the reigning D9 Class 2A champion. The Gremlins feature one of the county’s best players, quarterback/defensive back Cole Johnston, and skill position talent like Bryce Galan and Owen Kaufman. It will be a good challenge for Baggetta, quarterback Will Dunaway and the Tornado’s own collection of playmakers.
Last year yielded the Golden Tornado’s first winning season since 1997, but detractors discredit success with an “as you should” attitude. It takes time, Baggetta said, to build up a program.
“(It would be) such a good feeling to go to a Butler football game … and just watching them dominate in the WPIAL,” Baggetta said. “That would be such an amazing place to get to.”
But it may not be an easy destination to arrive to, not without support.
Editor's note: This story was updated at 6:45 p.m., Thursday, Oct. 15, 2026, with a corrected photo of Butler head coach Eric Christy.
