Site last updated: Sunday, September 27, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Pa. board accused of ignoring 'red flags' in kickback scandal

HARRISBURG — The Pennsylvania Judicial Conduct Board ignored "red flags" about a judge who took millions of dollars in kickbacks to place juveniles in for-profit detention centers, according to an investigator probing the "kids-for-cash" scandal in Luzerne County.

Kenneth Horoho, a member of a state panel investigating the failures in Luzerne County, questioned Tuesday why the conduct board sat on a 2006 complaint against former county judge Michael Conahan for years and did nothing with it before finally turning it over to federal prosecutors.

"You had red flags. You did nothing with these red flags," Horoho told conduct board chairman John Cellucci at a hearing in Harrisburg.

The conduct board, which investigates and prosecutes misconduct allegations against Pennsylvania judges, waited nine months before taking up the complaint against Conahan — and then tabled it without ordering its staff to conduct an investigation.

The eight-page complaint contained numerous allegations of cronyism and nepotism, accused Conahan of having mob ties, and, notably, mentioned his close friendship with an attorney who co-owned a Luzerne County detention center where thousands of juvenile offenders were being placed.

Conahan and another former Luzerne County judge, Mark Ciavarella, face federal racketeering charges for allegedly taking $2.8 million in payoffs from the attorney, Robert Powell, and from the builder of the detention center. The former judges have pleaded innocent and await trial.

Tuesday's hearing offered possible clues into why the conduct board failed to act on the anonymous complaint against Conahan.

The board's staff suspected, correctly as it turned out, it was sent by a staffer of former Luzerne County Judge Ann Lokuta, who at the time was the subject of a conduct board investigation in which Conahan was a key witness against her.

"There were suspicions that it came from Lokuta, somebody who already in our mind had suspect credibility," the conduct board's chief deputy counsel, Francis Puskas, testified Tuesday.

Members of the Interbranch Commission on Juvenile Justice also questioned witnesses on ties between Conahan and Luzerne County businessman Patrick Judge, who was chairman of the conduct board when the complaint against Conahan arrived in September 2006. Judge, who had financial dealings with Conahan in Florida and Pennsylvania, never disclosed his relationship with the jurist to the other board members, Cellucci said.

He said Judge recused himself in June 2007 when the conduct board voted to table the complaint, but did not explain the reason for the recusal. He said the complaint was tabled on the advice of the board's attorney, Joseph Massa Jr., because the judge was already under federal investigation.

More in Pennsylvania News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS