Site last updated: Sunday, August 9, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Empty envelopes lead to real criminal charges

Jason E. Vogan

A Butler man is accused of depositing empty envelopes into an ATM and withdrawing funds that he did not have, authorities said.

Jason E. Vogan, 43, managed to steal more than $2,400 in the alleged scheme, according to court documents.

Butler police Wednesday arrested Vogan on a felony charge of theft by deception. He was arraigned in the case and placed in the Butler County Prison.

While he was given a recognizance bond in the case he remains in the county jail on a bench warrant out of Venango County.

Police began their investigation Nov. 22 when an official with First National Bank filed a fraud report. The bank, according to court documents, identified the defendant as a customer who was making fraudulent deposits.

He is accused of making six deposits totaling $10,200 using empty envelopes that were deposited in June and July 2017 at the First Commonwealth Bank ATM in downtown Butler.

“Vogan then withdrew money,” according to a police affidavit, “prior to the discovery of the empty envelopes.”

More in Digital Media Exclusive

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS