Site last updated: Thursday, November 19, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Prepare for worst-case scenario

As powerful a blow as Hurricane Katrina delivered, what if the situation had been worse?

What if, for example, the storm system had produced the unexpected - as hurricanes appear prone to do in these crazy weather times - such as intensifying again to the 175-mph wind power it displayed briefly and taking a leisurely eastward jog?

Americans could have faced New Orleans-Biloxi-Gulfport-scale devastation from Louisiana to Florida's Panhandle.

And what if merchants of evil - the global terrorists who ally themselves with the element of surprise - had planned 9-11-magnitude attacks and just happened to unleash their horrors prior to or after the hurricane in multiple locations?

Americans could have faced a mixture of natural and human-inspired catastrophes of unprecedented proportions. In such circumstances, would they have been content with a perplexingly feeble federal government response, one that appeared to lack full understanding of the threat, a serious sense of urgency and a clear strategy? Is this what they deserve from a federal government that, since 9-11, presumably has operated at the apex of preparedness? Is this the best that the United States, the superpower that lends a global hand, can do for its own?

Quite frankly, the early federal reaction to Hurricane Katrina - especially in light of recent hurricanes - was a disappointment. As I listened to New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin say, "This is a desperate SOS," I immediately recalled Miami-Dade County Emergency Manager Kate Hale's post-Hurricane Andrew plea after three days without federal help: Where is the cavalry?

A comprehensive, flexible plan to deal with the worst-case scenario along the hurricane's probable path should have been in place. Supplies and transport vehicles sufficient to assist thousands of victims should have been readied. U.S. naval vessels and a sizable number of troops should have been prepared to move in as soon as the storm's winds subsided.

Anything less - and the early reaction was far less - could be construed here and abroad as clumsy, disorganized and insensitive to the requirements of people who did not need to endure suffering, indignity and death.

Now, as the U.S. government steps up its activities, dozens of other countries have offered condolences and, in some cases, aid. I was particularly struck by a note, dated Thursday, that Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon sent to President George W. Bush: "I would like to offer Israel's assistance in volunteering our medical teams, which include hundreds of doctors, nurses, technicians and other experts who specialize in trauma, natural disasters and public health. We also offer field hospitals, medical kits and equipment for temporary housing, re-enforcement for hospitals, or any other assistance that you may require. I was informed by my security establishment that these teams and equipment can be ready in 24 hours."

Such an offer, although welcome, provides a stark and embarrassing contrast to the initial U.S. response. How is it that Israel could muster necessary aid so quickly?

I am not minimizing the enormous task that the U.S. government faces in Hurricane Katrina's wake. But it does not help for decision-makers seemingly to engage in days of decapitated-chicken gyrations before embracing meaningful action.

I know from three of last year's hurricanes in Florida a little bit about what it feels like to be cut off for days from regular communication, electricity, telephones and other utilities. I can only imagine what a situation a thousand times worse would bring in terms of worry, discomfort and despair.

For now, we can best help the victims of Hurricane Katrina with money, blood donations and prayers. But for next time, which could come this very season and register far more dire consequences, we must shake off the facade of federal preparedness and replace it with substance.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS