OTHER VOICES
The Bush administration is accepting public comments through November on its latest fuel-saving proposal for minivans, trucks and sports utility vehicles.
Here's one: You've got to be kidding.
With gas prices averaging $2.62 a gallon nationally, the best the Department of Transportation could muster Tuesday was a new fuel-economy rule saving less than a month's worth of gas over 15 years.
Consumers spending $50 for a fill-up need more help than that. So does the nation, whose economy and national security hinge on the supply and price of oil.
A well-crafted fuel-economy rule could have set the United States on a path toward oil conservation.
Americans could drive vehicles that have the features they like, but still save significant amounts of fuel over time. This proposal, at best, does nothing to meet that goal; worse, it creates new loopholes that may increase dependence on foreign oil.
Under the corporate average fuel-economy system adopted in 1975, an auto company's entire line of light trucks, SUVs and minivans had to average 21.6 miles per gallon. Automakers met that rule by producing one class of smaller, efficient vehicles to offset gas-guzzlers.
The new system creates six separate categories, based on size, each with its own fuel standard. Passenger cars are not affected.
For example, a small SUV such as a Honda CRV would be required to get 28.4 m.p.g, while a Dodge Ram pickup would need 21.3 m.p.g. The new system inexplicably exempts the greedy behemoths - Hummers, Excursions and the like.
A tiered system might actually have spread gas-mileage savings among all types of vehicles - if only mileage goals had been set higher and safeguards had prevented automakers from gaming the system. In 2002, the National Academy of Sciences determined that, with available technology and without compromising safety, SUVs and minivans could achieve gas mileage in the 30s. Inching up a half-mile a year, this rule falls woefully short of that goal.
The rule may perversely encourage companies to make their more efficient SUVs bigger, to qualify for lower mileage standards. For example, Subaru's Outback could slip into a more lenient category by becoming one inch wider and longer.
The Big Three already are reacting to pump prices by offering deep discounts on inefficient SUVs. That bolsters the short-term bottom line, but does nothing to address the long-range drain on oil supplies or the probability of continued high gas prices.
Detroit automakers have an unbroken record of resisting needed innovations in safety and fuel economy. In the 1970s, fuel-economy standards helped drag them, squawking, into the future.
The same is true today. They have the technology to take some pain out of the pump. They should use it.
